General Category > General Discussion
What do people here think of Germans?
mord:
Again why has'nt the original poster ever retuirned to see the answers to his question
Rubystars:
--- Quote from: mord on October 15, 2008, 08:26:45 AM ---Again why has'nt the original poster ever retuirned to see the answers to his question
--- End quote ---
He was probably just trolling. That's a typical troll type of question to ask on a Jewish message board. At least it turned out for the positive in my opinion, it let people discuss their views and no big arguments started. 8)
Future topics I expect are things like "What do people here think of Greenland?"
mord:
--- Quote from: Rubystars on October 15, 2008, 09:54:42 AM ---
--- Quote from: mord on October 15, 2008, 08:26:45 AM ---Again why has'nt the original poster ever retuirned to see the answers to his question
--- End quote ---
He was probably just trolling. That's a typical troll type of question to ask on a Jewish message board. At least it turned out for the positive in my opinion, it let people discuss their views and no big arguments started. 8)
Future topics I expect are things like "What do people here think of Greenland?"
--- End quote ---
humm let me think :laugh:
HEBREWHONOR:
--- Quote from: Rubystars on October 15, 2008, 08:13:56 AM ---
--- Quote from: HEBREWHONOR on October 15, 2008, 07:34:47 AM ---i cannot forgive germans for what they did , the only germans i am willing to not see a part of it , are noahides , for obvious reasons .
--- End quote ---
Why not any good person who is not the enemy of the Jews? Hating someone for their nationality is racist. You should be angry if someone is behaving badly.
--- End quote ---
i am not a racist , i dont belive that there are human races , but human cultures
if someone consider himself a german , he consider himself a part of the culture , which tried to wipe jews out ... i cannot say that there were no good german people , but there weren't enough , not by a long shot .... most of this nation chose to be my enemy at a certine time and a certine place , and because of their acts , 6 million jews died
you and i hate the arabs for far less
so ...
the only german i dont see a part of this culture , is nohaide , because he repaced his culture , to a culture given by my g-d ...
of course , any german that would technically "betray" sort of speak his german culture .. would not be considered really german to me ... but that doesn't mean i need to like him
Rubystars:
--- Quote from: HEBREWHONOR on October 15, 2008, 11:07:01 AM ---i am not a racist , i dont belive that there are human races , but human cultures
--- End quote ---
I believe in many ways culture proceeds from race, though individuals can always make a different choice. I wouldn't be who I am today if I weren't part of the white race and didn't have the heritage I hold. Maybe I wouldn't be as interested in science for example if I didn't have ancestors that came from a nation with many scientists.
--- Quote ---if someone consider himself a german , he consider himself a part of the culture , which tried to wipe jews out ...
--- End quote ---
Not necessarily. I consider myself an American and I don't agree with a lot of things in American culture of the last several decades, but I'm still proud to be an American.
--- Quote ---i cannot say that there were no good german people , but there weren't enough , not by a long shot .... most of this nation chose to be my enemy at a certine time and a certine place , and because of their acts , 6 million jews died
you and i hate the arabs for far less
so ...
--- End quote ---
I think I understand where you're coming from, but I think condemning an entire ethnicity for the actions that happened within a very short span of time during that nation's history is wrong too. I mean nobody likes it when Jewish people as a whole are blamed for someone like George Soros. Does he make you less proud to be Jewish? He shouldn't, he's an evil man with an agenda that is hurting a lot of people, but he doesn't represent Jewish people as a whole.
--- Quote ---the only german i dont see a part of this culture , is nohaide , because he repaced his culture , to a culture given by my g-d ...
of course , any german that would technically "betray" sort of speak his german culture .. would not be considered really german to me ... but that doesn't mean i need to like him
--- End quote ---
What about the Germans who hid Jews during the Holocaust or helped them escape, and were subsequently punished for it? Are they righteous Gentiles even if they were, for example, Catholics?
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version