Torah and Jewish Idea > Torah and Jewish Idea
Breakdown of the Halakhic System - Two Earth-Shattering Shiurim - Exclusive
q_q_:
--- Quote from: Lubab on June 29, 2008, 04:54:45 PM ---<snip>
You didn't read my posts fully. I addressed that statement. I don't believe every Rabbi's statement is true. Just the the sages from the Shach and Taz and prior which is completely consistent with this statement of the Rambam which is a guide for what to do in the future until today when many Rabbis have said many things that are downright wrong.
--- End quote ---
here is evidence that the RAMBAM did not hold by that at all..
This is a copy/paste from another thread where I quoted some maimonidean types.
"
Rambam follows R. Haaye Gaon... HaRambam has a famous teshuba where he
explains the entire history of his view of tefillim and how upon
seeing the version according to Ha'aye Gaon he threw away his old
tefillim from Spain.
"
judeanoncapta:
--- Quote from: q_q_ on June 29, 2008, 05:16:30 PM ---
--- Quote from: Lubab on June 29, 2008, 04:54:45 PM ---<snip>
You didn't read my posts fully. I addressed that statement. I don't believe every Rabbi's statement is true. Just the the sages from the Shach and Taz and prior which is completely consistent with this statement of the Rambam which is a guide for what to do in the future until today when many Rabbis have said many things that are downright wrong.
--- End quote ---
here is evidence that the RAMBAM did not hold by that at all..
This is a copy/paste from another thread where I quoted some maimonidean types.
"
Rambam follows R. Haaye Gaon... HaRambam has a famous teshuba where he
explains the entire history of his view of tefillim and how upon
seeing the version according to Ha'aye Gaon he threw away his old
tefillim from Spain.
"
--- End quote ---
That is incorrect.
The Rambam's tefilin opinion is the opposite of rav Hai Gaon. He must have mistook rav Hai Gaon for rav Saadya Gaon.
Lubab:
If I can answer both questions about Hagar and Keturah and the machloket on cooked vegetables to your satisfaction will you all become Chabad Chassidim?
;)
I will research and get back to you on both these points. I don't claim to know how to do this myself with every machloket but I know where to find the people who do...
q_q_:
--- Quote from: judeanoncapta on June 29, 2008, 05:20:24 PM ---
--- Quote from: q_q_ on June 29, 2008, 05:16:30 PM ---
--- Quote from: Lubab on June 29, 2008, 04:54:45 PM ---<snip>
You didn't read my posts fully. I addressed that statement. I don't believe every Rabbi's statement is true. Just the the sages from the Shach and Taz and prior which is completely consistent with this statement of the Rambam which is a guide for what to do in the future until today when many Rabbis have said many things that are downright wrong.
--- End quote ---
here is evidence that the RAMBAM did not hold by that at all..
This is a copy/paste from another thread where I quoted some maimonidean types.
"
Rambam follows R. Haaye Gaon... HaRambam has a famous teshuba where he
explains the entire history of his view of tefillim and how upon
seeing the version according to Ha'aye Gaon he threw away his old
tefillim from Spain.
"
--- End quote ---
That is incorrect.
The Rambam's tefilin opinion is the opposite of rav Hai Gaon. He must have mistook rav Hai Gaon for rav Saadya Gaon.
--- End quote ---
i'm glad you corrected that..
though if he did throw away a pair of teffilin that he thought went according to a wrong opinion, then the argument remains to lulab, amongst other arguments mentioned.
q_q_:
--- Quote from: Lubab on June 29, 2008, 05:32:30 PM ---If I can answer both questions about Hagar and Keturah and the machloket on cooked vegetables to your satisfaction will you all become Chabad Chassidim?
;)
I will research and get back to you on both these points. I don't claim to know how to do this myself with every machloket but I know where to find the people who do...
--- End quote ---
most important, is the quote from the shulchan aruch that you claim is the basis for this idea that all opinions from post gemara to taz and shach, are true.
it would be interesting to see your responses to those objections mentioned though.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version