Torah and Jewish Idea > Torah and Jewish Idea

Ask Judea Torah Show 9

(1/5) > >>

judeanoncapta:
Thank you all for your great questions. I can't wait to hear the new ones.

q_q_:
why is it that electricity is forbidden?

it is interesting that there is this -huge- conscusus, no disagreement infact, it seems. Yet it's something that is I imagine, interpretation, generalising a case.. Things that normally, not everybody would accept.
 
What is the basis and howcome there is such agreement? Is there even any disagreement?

q_q_:
2 questions here regarding how one can legally carry these things on shabbat.


Tissues (e.g. important if somebody has hayfever)

Map (could be just a page of a map).   (e.g. very useful if somebody has a bad sense of direction)

Suppose the situation is desperate. Would it be OK to stitch a page of map in a coat.. Do you have a better idea?

q_q_:
as a continuation from the previous question, of shabbat carrying conundrums. I would add another example of a problem , seeking your solution if possible!


A Coat.
One can wear a coat but not carry it.
Suppose you go when it's hot and return when it's cold. And would normally carry it there and wear in on returning.  It's too hot to wear it on the way there.  Too cold to come back without a coat.
Can you put it on your shoulders on your journey there and say it's a cape? So it's a piece of clothing you're wearing.
Similarly, a jumper as a scarf
How about wearing a "jumper" as a scarf on departure?
Or if dual function is no good , how about saying it's a garment(if halahically it has to have a name, then I can give it a name, and call it a G20) and it's shifted from being worn in one way to being worn in another way.

Tzvi Ben Roshel1:
What do you think is the reason the Beit Hamikdash was destroyed and we were exiled? (Is their 1 reason, or many?).

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page