Torah and Jewish Idea > Torah and Jewish Idea

What do most JTFers think of Rabin Assasination?

<< < (4/4)

DownwithIslam:
Of course it was a conspiracy and that Yigal Amir should be released immediately, but in any event, Rabin  more than deserved what he got for being a traitor to the jewish people.

Harzel:
It makes no sense that the Isreli Shabak purposely eliminated Rabin, why would they do that ? On the other hand Amir had a motive to kill Rabin and he did actually shot him.

I want an expert forensic opinion ruling out the possibility that Yigal Amir caused all the wounds with two shots. If what you say could be proved beyond doubt this would be devastating to the evil Israeli regime.

Unfortunately the Amona incidents is not very moving to most Israelis.

q_q_:

--- Quote from: Zelhar on November 23, 2008, 01:52:12 PM ---It makes no sense that the Isreli Shabak purposely eliminated Rabin, why would they do that ? On the other hand Amir had a motive to kill Rabin and he did actually shot him.

--- End quote ---

before you start jumping to conclusions. of who has a motive and who doesn't.

And even,

before you ask that question of where is the motive, you should ask the question of why it is relevant.

why do you need a motive?

Either the evidence proves it , or it doesn't, and if it doesn't, then a motive won't help it very much. We are talking about a very serious incident. Not something where one should say "Oh, HE had a motive, so then point the finger at him for that reason!".



--- Quote from: Zelhar on November 23, 2008, 01:52:12 PM ---I want an expert forensic opinion ruling out the possibility that Yigal Amir caused all the wounds with two shots. If what you say could be proved beyond doubt this would be devastating to the evil Israeli regime.

--- End quote ---

forget the number of shots.

I said.
Medical Records show that Rabin has wounds that could not have been inflicted by Yigal Amir.  You could ask me How I Know That.

You talk about asking a forensic expert as if you NEED that.  Your reasoning is flawed. (Now, I am not saying that experts have or haven't been consulted, that is not my point to you). My point is that your logic is flawed.
I happen to know of an expert in anatomy that says it's impossible, he is very highly qualified, but I have also found that he is not reliable.   Brilliant as he is, he is not logical.
You are going to have to look at this without being reliant on somebody else's Logic. You are going to have to use your own mind.
And THEIR expert information. That is their expertise, their knowledge.

That doesn't mean saying, they're an expert so everything they say is true.
You can say, They are an expert, so they know things and can provide you with information that you don't know.




--- Quote from: Zelhar on November 23, 2008, 01:52:12 PM ---Unfortunately the Amona incidents is not very moving to most Israelis.

--- End quote ---

If you see my post again, you will see I mentioned Amona to make a significant point related to this.  Not to ask that question and to open the doors for one to whine with some obvious answer.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page