What'd be R.Kahane's response to the Shalit kidnap?

[wonga66]

What would be Rav Kahane's Torah-true Halachic response to the Shalit kidnap?

For sure he would not hand over even one terrorist.

What does Chaim advocate?

Does he support these demos, even though their done by leftists?

Or would Chaim be even more schtark than R.Kahane, and give an ultimatum that one Hamas terrorist will be ecexuted each day until Shalit is released, thereby ensuring that the UN and NATO would invade Israel within the week?!

[muman613]

I suspect it may look something like this:



I believe what should have been done is a military rescue operation. I realize that such an operation is risky, and in the past we have lost brave Jewish soldiers when trying to rescue them.... But at least the terrorists will not accomplish their goals, and we can take out a bunch of them in one fell swoop...

[eb22]

What would be Rav Kahane's Torah-true Halachic response to the Shalit kidnap?

For sure he would not hand over even one terrorist.

What does Chaim advocate?

Does he support these demos, even though their done by leftists?

Or would Chaim be even more schtark than R.Kahane, and give an ultimatum that one Hamas terrorist will be ecexuted each day until Shalit is released, thereby ensuring that the UN and NATO would invade Israel within the week?!

It's safe to assume that there wouldn't be another kidnapping of an Israeli Jew if Rav. Kahane was alive and the Israeli P.M.    Or if Chaim became the Israeli P.M.      Their response would be appropriate and LONG OVERDUE!      The Muslim Nazi beasts and their supporters would have a much needed reality check!

[Ari Ben-Canaan]

I believe Chaim has stated that his response would include: [in all of Gaza] cutting off all electricity, cutting off all water, cutting off all food, and the demand for Shalit's immediate release before any of these things would be restored.  The only thing Koranimals understand is force [talk is beyond cheap, negotiation with terrorists is perverse].