Author Topic: Holy War - Jewish style!  (Read 437 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline muman613

  • Platinum JTF Member
  • **********
  • Posts: 29958
  • All souls praise Hashem, Hallelukah!
    • muman613 Torah Wisdom
Holy War - Jewish style!
« on: August 13, 2010, 04:36:11 PM »
This Shabbat Parasha contains the commandments concerning warfare..

http://neshamaart.com/Newsletter/Torah/New/D%27varim/Shoftim/Midrash.htm


B"H

 

SHOFTIM
Talmudic Sources                                                                                         

How a Jewish Army is Organized for War

In a war commanded by Hashem it is a mitzvah for each individual soldier not to be afraid of the enemy’s strength of numbers.

"When you go to war against your enemy and see a horse and a wagon, people more numerous than you, do not be afraid...." (20:21).

It says "a horse and a wagon," in the singular, to imply a Divine promise: "When the Jewish people fulfill My Will, all the enemies' horses and wagons (or other military equipment) will be like one before Me. You are superior to the enemies in good deeds, and you are descendants of the forefathers, to whom I swore to multiply their seed.

"Just as I brought you out of Egypt with miracles, so can I per­form miracles at any time of need."

Thus, after Bnai Yisrael crossed the Red Sea, they sang, "The horse and its rider He cast into the sea." Even though Pharaoh pur­sued the Jews with a large army, they were before G-d merely like one horse and one wagon.

Even though G-d does not want the Jewish people to rely on miracles, and therefore an army must be organized, a Jewish soldier is nevertheless forbidden to put his trust in the Jewish army, as it says (Tehillim 147:9-10), "He (G-d) does not want (one who trusts in) the horse's strength nor in the (swiftness of) man's legs. Hashem wants those who fear Him; those who hope for His kindness (who trust in His might rather than in human strength)."

During the battle a soldier may not think about his wife and children. He should bear in mind that victory or defeat is in G-d's hands. He has to do battle solely for Hashem's sake, and bear in mind that if he flees he will discourage others, and be held responsible for their retreat also. (According to Rambam (Hilchos Melachim 7:15), "One who fights wholeheartedly without fear and intends only to sanctify Hashem's Name is assured that no evil will come upon him and no harm will befall him." Nevertheless, Birkas Peretz comments that a soldier must be prepared to lose his life, since his thoughts may not be perfect and "Satan accuses at a critical time.")

The Torah commands the appointment of a special kohain, known as the mashuach milchama (the "kohain anointed for war," because he was consecrated with the oil of anointment), to teach the people the Torah commandments concerning warfare and to encourage them.

The kohain anointed for war addressed the people twice. The first time, at the border, before the army was mobilized, he read the verses:

"Any man belonging to one of the following categories may not take part in the war, but must leave the front:

Someone who recently built (or bought or inherited) a new home, and has not yet dedicated it by affixing a mezuza to the doorpost (that is, he has not yet lived in the house).

One who planted (or bought or inherited) a vineyard and the fourth year, in which its fruits are redeemed, has not yet arrived, so that he has never personally benefited from it.

One who betrothed a woman but has not yet married her."

The kohain's words are repeated by an officer, who adds:

"Whoever is faint-hearted and trembles at the sight of a drawn sword shall also return home."

All who withdrew had to prove the validity of their claim, with the exception of the faint-hearted. Those who left were required to perform support duties in the rear: clearing the roads, supplying the soldiers with food, and so on.

Why does the Torah disqualify the aforementioned groups of men from actual combat?

1. On a simple level, none of these men would make good soldiers, for their hearts would not be in the battle. The home owner dreams about the house in which he will never live if he dies in battle; the bridegroom about his marriage that may never take place, and so on. These groups will be quick to flee from the battlefield.

2. One of our Sages explains that "the fearful and faint-hearted" refers to one who is conscious that he has committed sins and is afraid that as a punishment he may fall in battle.

In order to spare the sinner the public shame of having to withdraw for this reason, G-d commanded that other groups - those who built a home, who planted a vineyard, who were betrothed and unmarried - also leave.

After commanding the judge Gidon to battle against Midyan, Hashem told him, "The people with you are too many for Me to deliver Midyan into their hands, lest the Jews pride themselves, saying, 'My hand has saved me.' Therefore, proclaim to the people: 'Whoever is fearful and trembling, let him return. (During the era of the judges, the Torah laws concerning selection of the soldiers did not apply. These laws are only in force under the ruling of the Jewish kings. Nevertheless, G-d commanded Gidon to dismiss the fearful.) He should leave Mt. Gilad early in the morning (at the time when people are still asleep, to spare him from shame!"

22,000 of the people returned, and 10,000 remained.

Hashem then said to Gidon, "The people are yet too many bring them down to the water and l will screen them for you there!"

After Gidon led the people to the water, G-d instructed him, "As­semble to you all those who lie down flat and lap the water like dogs, and put aside those who go down on their knees to drink."

Gidon divided the people - onIy three hundred had lapped the water Iying prostrate; all the rest had kneeled.

The Almighty then revealed to Gidon, "I will bring the victory through these three hundred men. (These are the tzaddikim; the rest kneeled down to drink because they are in the habit of kneeling before idols.)

G-d assists Jewish soldiers only if they are righteous. The Torah later warns that the army must maintain the highest levels of holiness, or else the shechina will depart.

After the army was organized and ready to fight, the kohain anointed for war addressed the people once again. His exhortation was repeated by another kohain.

He proclaimed in lashon hakodesh the verses:

"Shema Yisrael/Listen Yisrael! Today you are approaching war against your enemies. Let not your heart be faint; do not fear; do not tremble; and do not be terrified of them. For it is Hashem, your G-d, Who goes to fight with you (His holy ark, on which the shechina rests, is in your midst) against your enemies, to deliver you."

The prefatory "Shema Yisrael" implied: "If you have only the one merit of reciting the Shema every morning and night you deserve to be saved."

Why does recital of the Shema constitute such a great merit?

It is the most fundamental act of faith, whereby a Jew accepts G-d's authority upon himself.

Even the gentiles of old realized that the Jews were protected in the merit of reciting the Shema:

The Philistine giant Golias arrogantly and blasphemously challenged the Jews to appoint a champion to duel him. He would issue these challenges twice daily, in the mornings and at night, hoping that the Jews would assemble to listen and thereby forget the mitzva of reciting the Shema.

The kohain anointed for war encouraged the Jews with four expressions not to be afraid of the enemy, in order to counteract the four types of scare tactics employed by gentile armies:

1. They would clash their shields together to produce a thunderous metallic clanging sound.

2. They stamped their horses wildly and made them neigh.

3. They sounded their horns and trumpets.

4. They emitted loud, terrifying war cries.

Since these tactics usually caused fear and confusion among the enemy, the kohain warned the Jews:

1. Let not your hearts be faint (because of their horses' neighing).

2. Do not fear (their shields' clanging).

3. Do not tremble (upon hearing the trumpet blasts).

4. Do not be terrified (because of their war chants).

A military officer added the following proclamation which another officer repeated: "Who is afraid and faint-hearted? Let him return to his home, lest he make his brothers' hearts melt like his"

When Avraham heard that his nephew Lot was captured, he prepared his army for war according to Torah instructions.

Avraham called out before the battle: "Who is afraid of sins or evil deeds he has committed? Let him return home!"

[Rabbi Moshe Weissman, The Midrash Says, The narrative of the weekly Torah-portion in the perspective of our Sages Selected and adapted from the Talmud and Midrash, The Book of Devarim, p.234]


SHOFTIM

TALMUDIC SOURCES

The Mitzva to Appoint a Jewish King

After settling in the Land, the Jewish people are commanded three mitzvos:

1. To appoint a Jewish King, who will be chosen by G-d's prophet and by the Sanhedrin (Rabbinical Court).

2. To destroy Amalek.

3. To build the Bais Hamikdash.

 When the prophet Shmuel grew old, the Jews approached him and demanded, "You have aged and your sons don't follow in your ways. Give us a king to judge us like all the nations!"

Shmuel was exceedingly aggravated by their request and prayed to Hashem. G-d confirmed that the Jews had done wrong, but nevertheless told him, "Fulfill their request! Know that they have not rejected you but Me!"

Shmuel explained to the people that the king would be entitled to a 10% tax from their produce and animals, that he woud hire anyone he wished for his services, and that he would impose other hardships on them.

However, the people insisted. By G-d's order, Shmuel then anointed the first Jewish king, Shaul ben Kish.

The question arises why Shmuel and Hashem considered the people's request evil, since the Torah commands the appointment of a Jewish king.

There may be several answers to the query:

1. Their request was premature. As long as Shmuel was alive, G-d performed open miracles for Bnai Yisrael. Requesting another leader during Shmuel's lifetime constituted a rejection of the supernatural way of life they enjoyed.

2. The people's request was not for the sake of fulfilling the mitzva, but sprang from a desire to be ruled in a manner similar to the gentile nations around them.

Until Shmuel's time the Pelishtim, neighbors of the Jews, had been ruled by noblemen. However, during the period coinciding with Shmuel's government they began to appoint kings. Thus, by asking for a king, the Jews were actually imitating the Pelishtim and the other gentiles; they did not have the Torah commandments in mind.

3. According to a view of our Sages, only the unlearned among the Jews asked with sinful intentions, while the Elders requested a king solely for the sake of fulfilling the mitzva. Shmuel's anger was directed at those who had unworthy motives.

What is the proper role of a Jewish monarch?

His task is to lead the nation; to fortify and elevate the Torah so that the Jewish people are fully governed by halacha (Jewish code); to spread righteousness and justice in the world; to subdue the wicked; to wage the wars of Hashem; and to judge the Jewish people. He is meant to hold his position leshaim shamayim - performing all his functions for Hashem's sake.

[Rabbe Moshe Weissman, The Midrash Says, The Book of Devarim, p.214-215]

 

 
You shall make yourself the Festival of Sukkoth for seven days, when you gather in [the produce] from your threshing floor and your vat.And you shall rejoice in your Festival-you, and your son, and your daughter, and your manservant, and your maidservant, and the Levite, and the stranger, and the orphan, and the widow, who are within your cities
Duet 16:13-14

Offline muman613

  • Platinum JTF Member
  • **********
  • Posts: 29958
  • All souls praise Hashem, Hallelukah!
    • muman613 Torah Wisdom
Re: Holy War - Jewish style!
« Reply #1 on: August 13, 2010, 04:57:29 PM »
Another article from that site:



http://neshamaart.com/Newsletter/Torah/New/D%27varim/Shoftim/Articles/Dying_for_Life.htm

Dying for Life
By Lazer Gurkow

When our ancestors would mobilize their forces for war, they were addressed by a high ranking priest. First he would offer brave words of encouragement and confident predictions of victory. “Let your heart not be faint; do not fear the enemy nor enter into panic and do not be terrified for G-d will vanquish your enemy for you.”

The military officers would then announce: “Any man who has built a home, but has yet lived in it... planted a vineyard, but has yet to render it fit for use... betrothed a woman, but has not yet married her... should return home, lest he die in war....” (Deuteronomy 20)

This is an astounding time for such announcements. The priest has just bolstered the morale of the troops and the officers; yet now, it seems, he proceeds to demoralize them by thinning their ranks!

(There are a number of explanations that are offered by the commentaries for these announcements. Ibn Ezra1 argues that this was strategically wise. Men with such concerns on their mind will worry about their affairs at home and will be unable to keep their mind on the battle. Filling their ranks with such unmotivated troops would weaken the military and undermine their prospects for victory. Abarbanel2 argues that since these men did not have opportunity to fulfill the respective mitzvot associated with their endeavor (the house builder has yet to build his parapet, the vineyard planter has yet to offer the priestly gifts and the betrothed has yet to sire children) they would not merit the miracles required for victory.)

Protecting a Way of Life

The Talmud remarks that the order of these announcement reflect the proper conduct of life: First we ought to build a home, then plant a vineyard, or establish alternative sources of income, and only then should we marry.3 This remark indicates that our sages viewed these three announcements as a reflection on the ordinary routine of life.4

Why does an army go to war? To protect its national interest. What is a nation's primary interest? It's citizens' unhindered pursuit of life's ordinary routine. When an enemy threatens the ordinary pursuit of day to day life, the nation's very fabric is undermined.

In this way, perhaps we can explain the priest's public announcement of these exemptions from battle immediately following his words of encouragement. The troops were reminded of their exalted purpose. Why are we going to war? To enable our comrades to pursue the normal routine of life. So they can build homes, plant vineyards, and establish families.

The troops that were sent home knew that they were entitled to recuse themselves from military draft, but they came anyway. How could they not come? They could not sit home while their brothers fought for their country. It was not easy for them to abandon their brothers and go home.

Yet they were told to do just that. These soldiers, with their departure, validated their comrades' efforts on the battlefields. If they went to war, their comrades would die in vain.

Modern Application

When the enemies of Israel threaten our cities with rockets, when they threaten our lives with suicide bombers, when they send our citizens to bomb shelters and destroy our way of life, the nation is justified in going to war.

No argument can justify a cease fire that does not achieve the goals for which the nation set out to war. If our soldiers are not safe, if our borders are still violated and if our cities are still under attack then our war is not over.

We mourn the loss of innocent lives on all sides, our Torah ethic demand it. We pursue the war with a vengeance, till peace can be restored, our Torah ethic demands that too. We do not seek a peace that will lead to another war. We seek a war that will lead to a lasting peace. This is the unfortunate reality fostered upon us by our enemy.

We must embrace life. But if victory is not achieved, then those who have sacrificed their life will have died in vain. We cannot allow that to happen.

Fear Nothing, but Sin

Just before the army embarked for war, one last announcement was made. “He who is fearful and fainthearted should return home, lest he melt his brothers' heart as well.” There are those who fear the consequences of war, but such fear is intolerable in war. The Torah instructs us to keep such fears silent, lest they melt the hearts of the brave.

According to one of our sages this announcement was directed to sinners. An enemy that G-d promised to vanquish need only be feared if we were made unworthy by sin.5

Israel's destiny is in G-d's hands. We have no reason to fear our enemy, but we do have reason to fear our own sins. If we fear the odds in this war it is because we are not worthy of G-d's miracle. The obvious antidote is repentance.

This time of year is conducive to repentance. So let us repent this year not only for ourselves, but for our entire nation.

FOOTNOTES

1.
   

Rabbi Abraham ben Meir ibn Ezra, Spain, 1092–1167.

2.
   

Don Yitzchak Abarbanel, Spain, 1437-1508.

3.
   

Talmud, Sotah, 44a. See Maharsha, ibid., that this standard only applied to a person of means. One, who cannot afford to build his own house and business may marry on the basis that the community will support him till he finds an independent source of income.
Maimonides places house building ahead of vineyard planting. Many commentators have attempted to explain the seeming contradiction with the Talmudic statement.

4.
   

It is interesting to note that when G-d reprimands the Jews and warns of their impending punishment should they abandon the Torah the loss of these three freedoms are specified. “You will betroth a woman, but another man will lie with her, you will build a house, but another mail will live in it, you will plant a vineyard, but will not render it fit for use (Deuteronomy 28:30).

5.
   

Talmud, Sotah, 44a. See also Rashi's and Nachmanides' commentaries on Deuteronomy 20:9.
You shall make yourself the Festival of Sukkoth for seven days, when you gather in [the produce] from your threshing floor and your vat.And you shall rejoice in your Festival-you, and your son, and your daughter, and your manservant, and your maidservant, and the Levite, and the stranger, and the orphan, and the widow, who are within your cities
Duet 16:13-14

Offline MassuhDGoodName

  • Ultimate JTFer
  • *******
  • Posts: 4542
Re: Holy War - Jewish style!
« Reply #2 on: August 14, 2010, 07:42:14 PM »
Re:  Jewish Warfare

muman613 and any members,

Are there any sources which give details of how the Jewish Armies would behave after a battle, as regards their dead and wounded?

For example:  It is well known that the Roman Legions went around after a battle and killed all of their wounded men by stabbing them in the throat with a sword - they took with them none who were seriously wounded and required attention, so they wouldn't have anything to slow down their march.

So I'm curious to know if there is any reliable material on this subject, as well as whether or not Jewish Armies carried "surgeons" or "doctors" with them into battle for dealing with the wounded, etc. ....