Is Jorge "Asher" Meza really Jewish?

[ChabadKahanist]

Not only is not really a rabbi,but I suspect that his conversion may be phony as well or he did not have one at all.
When I asked him who was the bais din that did the giyur he would  not answer.
Kind of suspicious isn't it?

[Ephraim Ben Noach]

I don't think so... If anything, he's a renegade Convert. He's a real tool bag! He has said a lot of bad things about Noachides.

[Tag-MehirTzedek]

Not only is not really a rabbi,but I suspect that his conversion may be phony as well or he did not have one at all.
When I asked him who was the bais din that did the giyur he would  not answer.
Kind of suspicious isn't it?

 Does he owe you an answer. Guys please remember that the Torah tells us to be extra sensitive when it comes to converts. You are not allowed to remind them of who they were or to question their conversion. Are you planning to have your daughter marry him or his son or something? If not what business do you have either way?

[muman613]

Do we have to discuss this here? In the Torah section it may be appropriate but in the general section it seems like nothing more than Lashon Hara (or Motzi Shem Ra)... I ignore him and he goes away..

[Israel Chai]

No he isn't.

[Tag-MehirTzedek]

No he isn't.

Don't make an avera by writing something you don't know. Accusing someone of not being a convert when you don't even know who did his conversion is an avera whether you like him or not. Whether what he says is good and true or not either way, if he converted then he is a Jew.

[Israel Chai]

Don't make an avera by writing something you don't know. Accusing someone of not being a convert when you don't even know who did his conversion is an avera whether you like him or not. Whether what he says is good and true or not either way, if he converted then he is a Jew.

I talked to him. Word was that he had a Satmar conversion. There isn't any Satmar Rabbi anywhere claiming any affiliation. He won't say whether he's a Rabbi or not, and it's 100% obvious that he's not, but when you ask him if he's a Jew, he gets really offended. No Rabbi backs him up ever. His Rabbi would have stepped in already. We did research, and at least one of his outpoken supposed followers was an undercover baptist on facebook, so it's 99% likely he's a baptist minister, and .00000000001% likely he actually converted, and since he lies about being a Rabbi, that's almost 100% likely a Rabbi.

We did research after he came to JEWS FOR JUDAISM to promote that secular Jews convert to xtianity because he says it's better for them to loose their share in the world to come that way. If he says that there, I would bet there are sermons elsewhere. It's more of a sin to say that he's a Jew than he isn't.

[muman613]

Interesting but I will continue to ignore him because I am not sure if this is Lashon Hara or not. If he is not a Jew and he professes to be a Rabbi then we should warn people against him (and it would not be Lashon Hara because we are supposed to tell things to warn others)...

I just wish he would go away... What he says is not kosher in my book..

[Israel Chai]

Interesting but I will continue to ignore him because I am not sure if this is Lashon Hara or not. If he is not a Jew and he professes to be a Rabbi then we should warn people against him (and it would not be Lashon Hara because we are supposed to tell things to warn others)...

I just wish he would go away... What he says is not kosher in my book..

I know so if I don't inform the public, I'm guilty as he is. He's making a bunch of fake converts, that's why he wants to be called a "Rabbi". It's a more valuable conversion than deform, because he says "orthodox".

[Chaim Ben Pesach]

בס''ד

He is an enemy of the Jewish people. He is against the very existence of the State of Israel and he makes phony conversions. He also demands that all Gentiles convert to Judaism, not even offering them the option of being bnei Noach or chasidei umot haolam (the righteous among the nations). Everything he stands for is a Chillul Hashem (desecration of G-d's name). Everything he stands for is a complete distortion of authentic Torah Judaism.

[ChabadKahanist]

בס''ד

He is an enemy of the Jewish people. He is against the very existence of the State of Israel and he makes phony conversions. He also demands that all Gentiles convert to Judaism, not even offering them the option of being bnei Noach or chasidei umot haolam (the righteous among the nations). Everything he stands for is a Chillul Hashem (desecration of G-d's name). Everything he stands for is a complete distortion of authentic Torah Judaism.

Absolutely on spot Chaim & I have my doubts if he is really Jewish or not.