I've read only the second post (the first with text)
I'd like to say something about this:
There is a commandment even to go to war to conquer the Land of Israel (Rambam Hilchot Melachim 5,1; Ramban Sfer HaMitzvot, additions to Mitzvot Asei 4). The Torah repeatedly instructs the Jewish People in the desert to ready themselves for the battle against the Canaanite nations to liberate the Land that was promised to our forefathers.
Well, there's a problem with this: it can work
only if God is with Israel.
Remember Numbers 14:39-45, where it is also written:
Do not go up, for the Lord is not among you, [so that] you will not be beaten by your enemies.
And, as far as I remember, this would not be the first time the Jews would try to liberate their country. The Jews of the first centuries AD also believed they can break from the Roman Empire, but that attempt didn't work at all as expected. And, if I remember well, that was not the only failed attempt of the Jews that had bad repercussions to them.
So I believe that if the Israeli Jews would do something reckless, it's a great possibility that they would suffer a lot, no matter how much they trust that God would help.
Topic: Land for Peace: What is the Halacha? (Read 16723 times)