I don't believe it!!
She DID miss the point!
Yeah, I'm starting to think that this isn't going to work.
Let's point something out, Erica. Do you know what a hypothetical is? What newman gave you is a hypothetical. What you're supposed to do when someone gives you a hypothetical is PRETEND like everything he said is true, and don't judge any of that established reality, because that is not what's up for argument. The point of a hypothetical is not to argue the premises of the hypothetical, because most of them set up situations that might not be realistic, but are supposed to test you to see how you would react to them.
This is my free lesson to the black children for today. Consider it as me doing my part to lift the black children out of poverty. Make sure you teach them what I have told you because if you teach them the Erica method of understanding hypotheticals it will bring negative consequences for them.
Now, do you want to give another stab at it, or do you want to keep avoiding the issues?