0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
It's against Halacha to aid in idolatry.
Your halacha is stupid.It's a good thing that you are not calling the shots.
The halacha is stupid? Compared to what? Worshiping a dead man on a cross? That's what your beloved pilgrims do.
I said "your halacha" because "Binyamin Yisrae", who is not a halachic scholar, has a habit of cherry picking and interpreting the halacha in a way that will make his halacha indistinguishable from Islam.Other people do and believe in stupid things and things I believe in or do may seem stupid to you.
There's nothing wrong with his halacha. I am a scholar and I'm probably more radical than he is. You do you, but don't pretend that Christians are welcome in Israel just because you hate the Muslims more.
Are you a scholar of halacha? I don't pretend, Christians are welcome to visit Israel, worship according to their faith and do pilgrimage. Why should it bother you? Wouldn't the Jews look like complete a-holes if they said Christians are not allowed to worship in Israel but Jews of course must be able to worship in Poland or Croatia or wherever they may be? That is a sort of attitude I would expect from muslims but never from either Jews or Christians, or Noahides for that matter.
Yes, yes I am. Because I am a scholar of halacha, I know the clear Torah Law when it comes to Gentiles in the land of Israel. I believe you know it too because I cited it on this forum multiple times: non-Noahide Gentiles are forbidden by Torah Law to dwell in Israel and Jews are commanded to expel them. If you are worried so much about what Christians think of you, you can simply inform them that is the traditional Jewish understanding of what God commands.
As citizens. They can visit, and if they offer a sheep to be sacrificed to Hashem, they can. Maybe they'll pray to their idol in Israel, it's not something we do something about. Unless they're promoting it. Keeping it to that room is fine.
They can come but the government should not actively promote activities relating to idolatry. That includes using taxpayer money to build them prayer areas. Churches in Israel should be private Christian places and the government should not promote it. Let the churches promote themselves. Or course in a Halachic state, churches would be completely illegal in the Land of Israel.
They shouldn't be allowed to own our land, that's a serious halacha that Rav Kahane went on about. Better they do it in a room and no Jew goes in there then all over the airport.
You ignored my refutation of your argument. Just a friendly reminder.
You got your point through. They're going to come, they're going to pray, we don't need them to own our land to make it ok, they can have a little room.
This must be an example of the Jewish schizophrenia Rabbi Kahane spoke about. Well, you do you bro.