Rabbi Dr. Michael Schulman exposes the evil heretic Cherky

[Hrvatski Noahid]

https://www.facebook.com/groups/AskNoah.org/permalink/10158498263176201/?sfnsn=mo

[Chaim Ben Pesach]

https://www.facebook.com/groups/AskNoah.org/permalink/10158498263176201/?sfnsn=mo

בס''ד

Unlike you, Rabbi Shulman disagrees with HaRav Sherki but does NOT slander him and call him an "evil heretic". Your vicious slanderous attacks on HaRav Sherki are something NONE of the rabbis you cite would agree with.

Rabbi Shulman is also a Chabad rabbi. That means he is part of a small minority of Orthodox Jewry whose views are rejected by the overwhelming majority.

Hrvatski, since you agree with Chabad and call the religious nationalist rabbis that HaRav Sherki represents "evil heretics", that means you have to agree with Chabad on the following major issues:

*Chabad says Jews can, and in many cases should, live outside of Israel in the cursed exile. HaRav Sherki and the Rabbi Kook followers say that Jews MUST live within Israel now that Hashem has given us a Jewish state and has for more than 100 years fulfilled the prophesy of the ingathering of the exiles.

*Chabad says that the Lubavitcher rebbe was a prophet. The Rabbi Kook followers say that there is no prophesy since the destruction of the First Temple which is what it clearly says in the Talmud.

*Chabad says that the Lubavitcher rebbe never sinned, never was mistaken, was absolutely perfect, and was not a human being with free will. The Rabbi Kook followers say that even Abraham, Moses and David sinned as described in the Torah and the Bible - this clearly described in both the Oral and the Written Torah.

The Rabbi Kook/Rabbi Sherki view is traditional Torah Judaism which the vast majority of Orthodox Jews adhere to. It is Chabad that has created a new religion which the Vilna Gaon (the greatest Torah scholar in modern history) described as heresy. The Vilna Gaon excommunicated the Chabad followers.

[Hrvatski Noahid]

בס''ד

Unlike you, Rabbi Shulman disagrees with HaRav Sherki but does NOT slander him and call him an "evil heretic". Your vicious slanderous attacks on HaRav Sherki are something NONE of the rabbis you cite would agree with.

Rabbi Shulman is also a Chabad rabbi. That means he is part of a small minority of Orthodox Jewry whose views are rejected by the overwhelming majority.

Hrvatski, since you agree with Chabad and call the religious nationalist rabbis that HaRav Sherki represents "evil heretics", that means you have to agree with Chabad on the following major issues:

*Chabad says Jews can, and in many cases should, live outside of Israel in the cursed exile. HaRav Sherki and the Rabbi Kook followers say that Jews MUST live within Israel now that Hashem has given us a Jewish state and has for more than 100 years fulfilled the prophesy of the ingathering of the exiles.

*Chabad says that the Lubavitcher rebbe was a prophet. The Rabbi Kook followers say that there is no prophesy since the destruction of the First Temple which is what it clearly says in the Talmud.

*Chabad says that the Lubavitcher rebbe never sinned, never was mistaken, was absolutely perfect, and was not a human being with free will. The Rabbi Kook followers say that even Abraham, Moses and David sinned as described in the Torah and the Bible - this clearly described in both the Oral and the Written Torah.

The Rabbi Kook/Rabbi Sherki view is traditional Torah Judaism which the vast majority of Orthodox Jews adhere to. It is Chabad that has created a new religion which the Vilna Gaon (the greatest Torah scholar in modern history) described as heresy. The Vilna Gaon excommunicated the Chabad followers.

Chaim, when you write 704 pages explaining the Noahide laws like Rabbi Weiner did, you will get to lecture me on Noahide law. It is permissible to publicize the character of an evil person and his evil deeds, so that other people will be warned about him and will take care not be harmed by him, since the intention is to save others from harm (the Divine Code by Rabbi Moshe Weiner, Ask Noah International, 2011, p 456).

Despite your hatred of Chabad, I am a member of your organization because of Rabbi Weiner's holy writings. He teaches that Gentiles are obligated to save a person's life, which includes saving Jewish lives.

[Ron]

Comparing HaRav Cherky to Rabbi Schulman - who would never call HaRav Cherky like that, who with all due respect is essentially anonymous next to him, and who never produced anywhere near the volume of Torah literature that HaRav Cherky wrote, is pretty silly.

[Hrvatski Noahid]

Comparing HaRav Cherky to Rabbi Schulman - who would never call HaRav Cherky like that, who with all due respect is essentially anonymous next to him, and who never produced anywhere near the volume of Torah literature that HaRav Cherky wrote, is pretty silly.

Rabbi Schulman edited Rabbi Weiner's "The Divine Code," which is far more important in the Noahide world than anything Cherky wrote.

[Chaim Ben Pesach]

Rabbi Schulman edited Rabbi Weiner's "The Divine Code," which is far more important in the Noahide world than anything Cherky wrote.

בס''ד

Rabbi Weiner deserves to be praised for his work with the Noachides. He has certainly done many positive things and I praise his devotion to this very important cause.

But Chabad rabbis are simply wrong about Jews living outside of Israel, about worshipping the Lubavitcher rebbe, and about many other vital issues.

We love the Chabad Jews, they are wonderful people. But we disagree with some of their views.

[Chaim Ben Pesach]

Chaim, when you write 704 pages explaining the Noahide laws like Rabbi Weiner did, you will get to lecture me on Noahide law. It is permissible to publicize the character of an evil person and his evil deeds, so that other people will be warned about him and will take care not be harmed by him, since the intention is to save others from harm (the Divine Code by Rabbi Moshe Weiner, Ask Noah International, 2011, p 456).

Despite your hatred of Chabad, I am a member of your organization because of Rabbi Weiner's holy writings. He teaches that Gentiles are obligated to save a person's life, which includes saving Jewish lives.

בס''ד

I do NOT hate Chabad. G-d forbid! I love the Chabad Jews. They are wonderful people who genuinely love their fellow Jews and who really are devoted to helping the Noachides. But I disagree with Chabad on many fundamental issues and I base my disagreement on the teachings of the vast majority of Orthodox rabbis.

[edu]

I do not classify Rabbi Cherki as an evil heretic.

[Hrvatski Noahid]

I do not classify Rabbi Cherki as an evil heretic.

The prohibition against making a new religion or adding a commandment is a fundamental principle of the Torah based Noahide Code. Regardless of what argument is advanced, a person is a denier of the Torah (a kofer in Hebrew), if the ultimate result of his approach will be a negation of any of the Torah's precepts or fundamental principles.