General Category > General Discussion
The 2 Messiahs of Judaism; also healthy food that can save your life (JTF video)
Hrvatski Noahid:
--- Quote from: Dovid_2 on February 15, 2025, 10:39:07 PM ---You're aware that Rabbi Weiner must be deriving his conclusions from Rabbi Caro or Rabbi Isserles, yes (or perhaps Maimonidies)?
Sex is healthy for the body, the aforementioned Rabbi knew this in the 13th century, and even allows sex "for the body's physical health" when it is not done specifically to produce offspring. What you do with your semen is not my concern and quite frankly does not interest me.
--- End quote ---
Rabbi Weiner extensively researched and cited the broad spectrum of Rabbinical sources. The bibliography for The Divine Code is available here: https://asknoah.org/wp-content/uploads/the-divine-code-bibliography.pdf
Sex might be healthy for a Jewish body. It is not healthy for a Gentile man.
Dovid_2:
--- Quote from: Hrvatski Noahid on February 15, 2025, 10:53:20 PM ---Rabbi Weiner extensively researched and cited the broad spectrum of Rabbinical sources. The bibliography for The Divine Code is available here: https://asknoah.org/wp-content/uploads/the-divine-code-bibliography.pdf
--- End quote ---
Absent is his methodology for reaching a conclusion when the sources contradict each other -- but I won't get into that with you because such study has scholastic prerequisites which I have no doubt you lack.
--- Quote ---Sex might be healthy for a Jewish body. It is not healthy for a Gentile man.
--- End quote ---
The Jewish body and the Gentile body are indistinguishable. The science of medicine applies equitably to both.
Back to what I originally stated -- when the sages stated those effects, they were effecting an allegory, which is something they did quite often in the Talmud... I'm not going to get into it with you now, and I won't recommend any books on that matter because I think the language barrier in comprehending the material would be far too much for you.
But you go on holding up Rabbi Weiner's work as a bastion of light for the world -- just don't try to create your own 'new' ten commandments for the Jews.
Hrvatski Noahid:
--- Quote from: Dovid_2 on February 15, 2025, 11:11:35 PM ---Absent is his methodology for reaching a conclusion when the sources contradict each other -- but I won't get into that with you because such study has scholastic prerequisites which I have no doubt you lack.The Jewish body and the Gentile body are indistinguishable. The science of medicine applies equitably to both.
Back to what I originally stated -- when the sages stated those effects, they were effecting an allegory, which is something they did quite often in the Talmud... I'm not going to get into it with you now, and I won't recommend any books on that matter because I think the language barrier in comprehending the material would be far too much for you.
But you go on holding up Rabbi Weiner's work as a bastion of light for the world -- just don't try to create your own 'new' ten commandments for the Jews.
--- End quote ---
In the few cases where a majority of the other Rishon authorities and the Shulhan Aruh all differ from Rambam, Rabbi Weiner decided the Torah Law according to their teachings, and not according to the opinion of Rambam.
There are differences between a Jewish body and a Gentile body, and between a Jewish soul and a Gentile soul.
I didn't ask for any recommendations. I have all the sources I need to live as an observant Noahide.
Dovid_2:
--- Quote from: Hrvatski Noahid on February 15, 2025, 11:27:16 PM ---In the few cases where a majority of the other Rishon authorities and the Shulhan Aruh all differ from Rambam, Rabbi Weiner decided the Torah Law according to their teachings, and not according to the opinion of Rambam.
--- End quote ---
"According to their teachings" is meaningless and you are wasting everyone's time here with nonsensical non-answers like that. Please go educate yourself on the codification of Jewish law before pretending to assert yourself strongly on topics that you know nothing about.
--- Quote ---There are differences between a Jewish body and a Gentile body, and between a Jewish soul and a Gentile soul.
--- End quote ---
There are not differences between a Jewish and Gentile body. All human bodies from the species Homo Sapiens var Sapiens are essentially the same. They do not teach different types of medicine for Jews and Gentiles. This is a stupid assertion and you are making a fool out of yourself for claiming it.
Hrvatski Noahid:
--- Quote from: Dovid_2 on February 15, 2025, 11:38:07 PM ---"According to their teachings" is meaningless and you are wasting everyone's time here with nonsensical non-answers like that. Please go educate yourself on the codification of Jewish law before pretending to assert yourself strongly on topics that you know nothing about.There are not differences between a Jewish and Gentile body. All human bodies from the species Homo Sapiens var Sapiens are essentially the same. They do not teach different types of medicine for Jews and Gentiles. This is a stupid assertion and you are making a fool out of yourself for claiming it.
--- End quote ---
It's not meaningless. A specific example: by explaining the words of the Talmud in a completely spiritual context, Maimonides was bringing support for his opinion that the ultimate World to Come will be entirely spiritual, and that the righteous who merit it will exist there only as purified souls with no physical bodies, after a temporary period of physical resurrection. However, other Rishonim sages – including Nachmanides (see Sha'ar HaGmul) and Ra'avad (see his commentary on Mishneh Torah) – as well as the Chassidic masters, strongly disagreed and maintained that in the ultimate World to Come, the Essence of God will be revealed eternally to the righteous while they exist as souls living in their resurrected physical bodies, in the physical world.
Dr. Schulman claims there are differences between a Jewish and Gentile body. He is far more intelligent than you.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version