JTF.ORG Forum
General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: ChabadKahanist on September 12, 2021, 04:04:26 AM
-
https://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/313319
-
Bennett was mechalel shabbat & without any heter from a rav & nobody seems to care to comment about this
-
Bennett was mechalel shabbat & without any heter from a rav & nobody seems to care to comment about this
How is it not pikuah nefesh to capture these scum?
-
How is it not pikuah nefesh to capture these scum?
It was not pikuach nefesh for Bennett to be there &his presence was not essential he was definately mechalel shabbat!!!
-
Only police,border police,Shabak & the IDF were needed to accomplish this so Bennett being there was not needed!!!!
-
Only police,border police,Shabak & the IDF were needed to accomplish this so Bennett being there was not needed!!!!
How do you know? Perhaps he had to be there to make some tactical/political decisions
-
How do you know? Perhaps he had to be there to make some tactical/political decisions
There is no tactical decision that can not be made without him it was not pikuach nefesh
-
How is it not Pikuah Nefesh? These terrorists know that they can be captured and its a high chance that they want to murder again especially if they believe they could be captured.
-
Because his presence was not essential to capturing the terrorists so it was not pikuach nefesh
-
How can that b possible? In US, President is Commander in Chief. In such an operation, POTUS would be the 1 making final & highest level decisions. For natl security purposes, he absolutely should b there as integral part of operation leadership. Is this not the same case for Israeli Prime Minister?
-
Learn the halachot of pikuach nefesh the capture could have been accomplished without him breaking shabbat therefore it is not pikuach nefesh
-
Even Netanyahu who is not observant was apalled at Bennett's flagrant violation og shabbat when he was not need there/
-
Learn the halachot of pikuach nefesh
You didn't answer the question
-
The capture could have been accomplished without him breaking shabbat & physically being there therefore it is not pikuach nefesh
-
There is no heter to break shabbat unless it is absolutely pikuach nefesh & his presence was unecessary therefore chilul shabbat
-
In micro situations such as catching prison escapees, the Israeli PM (or POTUS for that matter) doesnt add any value, operational or otherwise, it is all up to the police/intelligence agencies/army. The politicians are only there for the photo-op (which was Chilul Shabbat on its own).
-
Can't he give the orders remotely? Did Donald Trump go in person whenever he ordered the army to kill a terrorist? Obviously a phone call is less Chillul Shabbat than travelling.
-
The soldiers are permitted to travel on Shabbat. If Bennett himself was leading the battle, he could have gone but modern day heads of state are not soldiers (except among Muslim Nazi and other dictatorship regimes).
-
There is no heter to break shabbat unless
You keep asserting that he wasnt necessary to be there but I can't see how that's true.
-
See what Ron said above also hear what Chaim says on Ask JTF
-
:usa+israel: :fist:
If Bennett illogically deemed this frivolity as some
type of necessity, it should have been handled
in a manner not in violation of Shabbat.