JTF.ORG Forum
General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: Yisrael on October 30, 2007, 12:43:22 PM
-
I think that every weak we should award a Most Valuable Member award to the member that contributed the most that week to the forum. And then that should be the only way to get the wings.
-
Good idea !
-
I think that every weak we should award a Most Valuable Member award to the member that contributed the most that week to the forum. And then that should be the only way to get the wings.
Great seggestion, but there are member that contributed the forum on weekly basis, what about them ?
-
Excellent Point! Let's do it... O0
-
I don't think we should make participation on the forum a contest or just throw wings around.
The whole point of the wings or an appointment will loose it's meaning.
I know there are alot of forum members who work at jobs or have obligations which prevent them from participating as much as they would like.
-
Members can nominate people and then we can vote for the Most Valuable Member of that week.
bullcat3, all forum members are valuable and precious, but this would be a reward for those that do something extra or special.
-
And you can't really base it on quantity of posts.
-
Because certain unscrupulous individuals would take advantage of it.
-
Just to inflate their number of posts.
-
It would detract from the content of the forum.
-
If you know what I mean.
-
Members can nominate people and then we can vote for the Most Valuable Member of that week.
bullcat3, all forum members are valuable and precious, but this would be a reward for those that do something extra or special.
Congratulations on having over 500 great posts! O0 8;)
-
4 posts sequencely ?
Anyway, I think the solution will be two Honorable ranks:
Silver Wings (For one week)
Gold Wings (For always)
-
Members can nominate people and then we can vote for the Most Valuable Member of that week.
bullcat3, all forum members are valuable and precious, but this would be a reward for those that do something extra or special.
Congratulations on having over 500 great posts! O0 8;)
Thanks, but it was a cheap way to earn the last few.
-
4 posts sequencely ?
Anyway, I think the sulotion will be two Honorable ranks:
Silver Wings (For one week)
Gold Wings (For always)
That sounds like a great idea Dexter!
-
Members can nominate people and then we can vote for the Most Valuable Member of that week.
bullcat3, all forum members are valuable and precious, but this would be a reward for those that do something extra or special.
Congratulations on having over 500 great posts! O0 8;)
Thanks, but it was a cheap way to earn the last few.
Oops, I see you meant Yisrael.
-
Members can nominate people and then we can vote for the Most Valuable Member of that week.
bullcat3, all forum members are valuable and precious, but this would be a reward for those that do something extra or special.
Congratulations on having over 500 great posts! O0 8;)
Thanks, but it was a cheap way to earn the last few.
I meant Yisrael who also just made 500 posts...but Congratulations HiWarp.
You are a great poster and JTF is lucky you are here.
However you make 500 posts - they all count ;)!
Congratulations again. 8;)
-
I couldn't care less about the amount of posts I have. Those weren't "cheap" posts in the sense that I posted them to get my post count higher. I didn't even notice I passed 500 until you guys mentioned it.
Anyway, Dexter had a good idea.
-
Now I'm confused, you said that it was a cheap way for you to earn the last few?
-
Sorry - Yisrael's came up first. :) but I always get excited when I get close to hitting a big number of posts! I would've done the same thing for the fun of it!
-
Members can nominate people and then we can vote for the Most Valuable Member of that week.
bullcat3, all forum members are valuable and precious, but this would be a reward for those that do something extra or special.
Congratulations on having over 500 great posts! O0 8;)
Thanks, but it was a cheap way to earn the last few.
Oops, I see you meant Yisrael.
Congratulations for having 500 posts HiWarp!
If there will be an agreement on Yisrael's idea we should have a redistribution of the wings.
-
Now I'm confused, you said that it was a cheap way for you to earn the last few?
Yes, in trying to make my point I had 5 ridiculous posts in a row which took me above 500. I was referring to MY cheap posts.
And thanks, Bullcat.
-
Can we have a 'least valuable member' award? The winner (or loser) will receive two front-row tickets to a Hillary Clinton fund-raiser.
-
I was referring to MY cheap posts.
Oh, lol, ok...
-
I got your point ;) but I'm still glad you made 500!
-
No! There would be too much pressure to avoid that nightmare :o
-
Can we have a 'least valuable member' award? The winner (or loser) will receive two front-row tickets to a Hillary Clinton fund-raiser.
Wouldn't work. The least valuable member is probably someone who supports Hillary Clinton, why reward them?
-
Can we have a 'least valuable member' award? The winner (or loser) will receive two front-row tickets to a Hillary Clinton fund-raiser.
Add a personal introduction to Hillary where you actually shake her hand and kiss her and you're bordering on torture. :P
-
Add a personal introduction to Hillary where you actually shake her hand and kiss her and you're bordering on torture. :P
No one here deserves that. NO ONE.
-
I think that I should be considered the most valuable. Look at how many posts I have.
-
If you know what I mean.
NO I don't can you give me an example :::D
-
For affirmative action mathematicians, only 45 of over 900 people have wings under their name.
affirmative action :::D
-
I'm all for dealing out accolades, but at some point I think we have to stop the self-congratulations and just work for the cause together as a movement. As Chaim pointed out in the recent Ask JTF, we would be that much stronger if there weren't separate factions supposedly working towards the same cause. We need to work together more.
-
I think that every weak we should award a Most Valuable Member award to the member that contributed the most that week to the forum. And then that should be the only way to get the wings.
can someone get a repeat award each week?
-
I don't like this idea. Wings are permanent...
can someone get a repeat award each week?
I meant that every week one person get the wings and gets to keep them permanently. Anyone can nominate a member and then we hold weekly elections. I guess there should be some regulations about who can be nominated (e.g. min posts or min time on the forum). And there should be regulations as to who can vote. (min posts/min time on forum).
And maybe they don't have to be wings. Maybe they can be a trophy or something like that.
-
I meant we disregard the vote of those with less posts.
We don't do a poll, we all post out in the open who we support.
OR, you can make a group of "veteran" posters and make a 'veterans' only forum, like you have with the mods only forum. And you can vote there.
-
That section can be used for voting only.