JTF.ORG Forum
General Category => Ask JTF => Topic started by: admin on December 03, 2006, 12:56:16 AM
-
BS"D
Note To All Posters: Only one post per person is permitted. Please make it a single, short question.
Chaim would love to answer all of your great questions but (unfortunately due to the number of questions and time constraints), if there is more than one short question, it will have to be moved to The Future Ask JTF Section. We apologize for this inconvenience and only wish that every person has a chance to be heard on the show.
Or course, comments not directed to Chaim will be moved into a separate thread under The General Discussion.
Chaim has stated that only one short question or comment per poster will be answered. Please remember that even with these rules, the program is over 2 hours long every week! If you want to post a longer question, unfortunately, Chaim may or may not be able to answer it in it's entirety. In this case, you may copy and paste parts of your question for the following week.
Thank you for your kindness and respect regarding these rules.
_________________________________________________________________________________________
BS"D
Dear Chaim,
Do you think of Canadian Indians in the same favorable manner you think of American Indians? What about The Aborigines in Australia and The Maoris in New Zealand? As the natives, do they have rights to be be in those countries like American Indians have the right to be here or are they a threat to the local white Anglo majorities? I know Newman speaks poorly of "The Abbos" in Australia like we speak of American blacks.
Yacov Menashe Ben Rachamim,
Chief Administrator.
-
I'm posting this for Yacov Menashe Ben Rachamim.
What do you think about Canada's Conservative Party? Tovia Singer is a friend of one of their leaders and he said they are Pro-Israel. Are they more Pro-Israel than The Republican Party? Are they more Pro-American than American traitors like George Wahabi Bush?
-
Dear Chaim
Have you ever considered hosting a talk radio program. You would without a doubt be a hit
-
Yacov,
This is my Ask JTF question for the week of January 13, 2008. I am posting it now because I will not have my computer this Sunday. I will be taking my computer to my cousin again for more adware removal this Saturday, and therefore won't have its services. So, here goes...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shalom Chaim,
The way I see it, California is a lot like Israel: dominated by a fascistic wealthy elite, comprised primarily of secular, left-wing citizens, being overtaken by a terrible Third World internal/external enemy, but possessing an underrated and substantial right-wing minority. Believe it or not, most of us do not worship Hollywood. While average Californians are left-of-center, I don't think they are completely beyond hope. People here don't want drivers' licenses for illegals or tax raises. We are more materialistic than anything else, and I think average Californians would vote for someone they really believe would make their lives better.
California has not had a strong, decently-funded Republican statewide candidate in a decade. It's hard to make definitive statements about who is electable here and who isn't when in nearly every race, the Democratic office-seeker outspends the GOP contender by fifty to one or more. When Pete Wilson ran for reelection in 1994, he went from being 20 points behind Kathleen Brown to beating her by the same percentage, because of his relentless anti-illegal-immigration campaign. The voters did not care that 24/7, the media was denouncing him as a racist. They voted for the man they wanted in office.
Chaimfan
-
Greetings Chaim
If Hillary, Obama, or McCain win, do you think it's a real danger that there may not be a United States at the end of their first term, having been absorbed into the planned North American Union?
-
Dear Chaim,
Will women serve in the Army of Israel under your leadership?
As a future minister of defense I gotta know these kinds of answers not to contradict with the official line. 8;)
Jokes aside, please elaborate on this subject.
Thank you, Sir.
-
Hello Chaim,
Somebody told me he thinks Hamas is funded by Israel.
His explanation was that he doesn't understand why so little of the Hamas leaders are being taken out by missile attacks.
He claims that the Israeli "refusal" to eliminate Hamas-leaders is a proof , Israel aids, or even funds Hamas.
Even if this is a complete lie, does he have a point that more Hamas-leaders can and should be assassinated?
-
Shalom Chaim-hope all is well
The reason why political correctness has failed is because there is a double standard to it. Evil people are allowed to be evil, but righteous people are vindicatd for being righteous. I think political correctness can be a benefit to an angry society, but only if it is used properly without these double standards. What can we do to be decent to each other while at the same time fight against evil and be vigilant?
With this being said, you are the only "hard-liner" I know of who can bring people with different opinions and cultures and religions together, while other hardliners are so extreme that they want to get rid of everyone that remotely disagrees with them. You are a true peacemaker. You are not a shallow racist where you judge people by their DNA like others have tried to in the past. You have a real vision for the future..and it's a righteous great wonderful vision. This is why I have stuck with you for the past year or so. You love Gd, you love humanity, and you love life so much that you are willing to die for it.
Thank you
Dr. Dan
-
Dear Chaim,
Do you think Huckabee will win the other states? He won Iowa, if we in JTF support him we'll have more votes going his way.
G-d Bless,
-JTFFan
-
Note From Yacov: I was reading this just before Shabbat and noticed the term "affirmative BLACKtion", a term Chaim Jr. came up with. I then traced him and found out that he shares an IP with JTF Enthusiast. It says JTF Enthusiast is banned under the ban name "Chaim Junior". So I then banned him and his IP and when he tries to get on the forum he will see this message: "You are a moser whom we pray against 3 times a day.".
Please read and respond to Chaim Jr.'s message even though he is banned so you can "skewer him" (In the words of Lisa.).
The Republicans cannot elect someone at their convention who is electable in November. Let us assume that the Democratic choice going into their convention is either Hitlery or Baruch O'Bama (half Jewish and half Irish). Of these two monsters, I would rather see O'Bama get elected president. I am not a guilt-ridden affirmative BLACKtion Jew like those Lynn Samuels kikes. I won't vote for either but ALL cowardly candidates of BOTH parties push affirmative BLACKtion. The spear chuckers get everything anyway, NO MATTER WHAT; so, give them the f*ing White House. This country's finished anyway. Anything rather than seeing the beast Clinton family get back in. I'd rather see Sharpton, all 350 pounds of blubber, in the White House than see another Clinton. I'd even rather see Joe Lieberman, his wife Hadassah, and his three daughters, B'nai B'rith, UJA and UJF.
-
Dear Chaim,
What do you think of Romania?
-
Hello Chaim,
I've heard many political experts say that even after Super Tuesday Feb 5, there will be no decisive GOP candidate... some say that it might take even up to the National Convention. Do you think this is a white wash of the republican party as a whole by the media?
As they feels that the GOP candidate would be irrelevant in the general election anyway...
Thanks as always
Dan
-
Dear Hayim,
If you knew that the Democrat would DEFINATELY win the presidency in November and you could choose which one of them would win, who would you choose?
Who is the lesser of those evils?
-
Shalom Chaim,
I know that you want the USA to stop foreign aid to Israel.
My question is, which president would be better. One that would cut all foreign aid to Israel, or one that will triple the foreign aid and put pressure on Israel to secure itself and throw out the Arab enemy?
Thanks,
Yisrael
-
mr.chaim whay don't you pleae to member for more money and try to have 1 comercial on radio(WOR in new york-am)for jtf!let's try it for a month and see what happends!i will first send $200.do we wont to be mass movement?let's do something about it!we got nothing to loos!just make it powerfull and i don't think we can faile!youtube is not enife becose over there most are kids who don't even have pocket money!can you call that radio station and see how much would be commercal for a month and let as set the gold to raise the money for radio commercial !most members we ever have on jtf was 615 in july 07 so in my opinion something is broken,it's not working so it's our obligation of all jtf members to fix it!please help me out i realy wont us to be mass movement!thank you and g-d bless you for all the work you do for serbian people!if i was the president of my contry i would donate millions to jtf and give you medal of honer!thank you one more time!
-
Hello Chaim,
As this being my first question on Ask JTF... I want to know your opinion on the following:
Do you think it's worth it for a foreign(Romanian) Medical Doctor to come and practice in America?
I'm on this journey right now and I've seen some of the local hospitals in Queens as I'm interviewing for a residency position...
It's unbelievable what type of people are in there working, is there any hope in sight!?
Thanks a Bunch, I love your shows
Jasmina
-
What do you think of Samuel Huntington, who wrote "The Clash of Civilizations, and the Remaking of World Order"?
-
Hello Chaim
I just got finished hearing the audio for last week and yes of course I will campaign against McPain. I call him Kennedy Lite. And I hope and pray we do not get a pick between McPain and one of the Democrats. I hate to see it come down to that but we are in a sick society that they like the worst that they can find, if it comes down to that God forbid what do we do from there? People are so obsessed with Britney's life and these idiots in Hollyweird that they do not see we are may end up with the enemy within the White House, I heard once Bridgette Gabriel mentioning this that the Muslims can not wait to put one of their own in the White House cause that is part of their Jihad to claim their biggest obstruction the United States. And dumb self hating morons who are the ones obsessed over Britney are the ones who are thrilled about Bongo Obama Osama.
Now from the date I am posting this, I don't know what the outcome of NH will be. But I will put up a major fight with my mailing list and any other way to stop McPain. Regardless of our slight differnces about Huckabee and Giulianni. But this is a common ground about McPain. And to me Romney is too polished like a used car saleman.
-
Hello Chaim
I'm not really asking a question, I just have a few things to say, this is intended more as a personal message to you, and I ask that you read all of it to yourself at least.
I am the person who previously posted as ftf, I created this new account primarily to give my email address to a few people here that I wish to stay in contact with, despite what you said on last weeks ask JTF, my account was deleted by and administrator and my IP was banned, I have often told the admins that anyone who knows what they're doing can evade an IP ban, I didn't think I'd be the one to prove it to them...
I am not going to remain a poster on this forum, due primarily to the things that have been said about me previously, I admit, yes, that I was negative about Judaism, however, this does not make me a "liberalist", "a muslim apologist", or a nazi. I love the Jewish people, and wish to support Israel, though I dislike some aspects of their religion, I dislike some aspects of all religions other than my own, or said other religions would be my religion, the same is surely the case for everyone, a Jew has to have a negative opinion of the Christian Bible, or they'd be a Christian, same applies for Hindus, Buddhists or Sikhs. I'd also like to add, that contrary to what some people have been posting, my primary source for the little information I have on the talmud, is Jewish websites, or at least websites claiming to be Jewish.
Regarding what has been said of Allen-T, I truly believe that you misunderstood him, and that your opinion of him is misplaced. I do not think he hates anyone.
I believe that while I agree with the primary stated aims of JTF, it can never be successful in achieving them, and it will never be a mass movement if it continues to act in the way it currently does. On this forum, if you disagree with the majority on a given issue, often even a minor one, no matter what the issue, you are instantly called a nazi, a liberalist and possibly a muslim apologist, I have seen this occur to many people here, and I can understand therefore them leaving however many issues they agree with JTF on.
I'm sorry that we cannot work together any further, and I truly hope that JTF's primary stated aims are achieved, I want the nation of Israel to survive as a primarily Jewish nation and become stronger, I want Serbia to survive and become stronger, I want the USA and the UK and other European nations to understand the threat that Islam represents before it is too late, and I want the threat that Islam represents to be neutralised, the attitude of members of this forum has however displayed to me that this is not a group I can work with to try and achieve these aims, I am hoping I will be able to find a group with a higher chance of success, or set one up myself.
I hope we can part without any lasting enmity, though I fear that this will not be the case.
Goodbye, and farewell.
-
Do you think that Huckabee is better than the other candidates (either democrate or republican) against big business abuses ? ...and why?
-
Dear Chaim,
I have observed that Judaism seems to be very weak at proselytizing and conversion of non-Jews to our beliefs, contrary to Christianity and Islam. Can you comment on this phenomenon and what you think could/should be done?
Thank you for all your work on behalf of our people.
-
Shalom Chaim,
More Chaim with permission - for your thoughts on Chief British Rabbit, Dr. Jonathan Sacks’s views - from his new book. He argues that he is not politically correct! and says, even more absurdly, that Jews have many friends who will “fight for us” (heh heh!), such as Muslims!!
Finally Sacks suggests Jews not hate the anti-semite, as hating doesn’t allow us to be “truly free” – we should “let go of hate” – like the Torah tells us, he says, not to hate the Egyptians who enslaved us!
Anti-semitism is denying a Jewish state when Muslims have 52 countries, Christians 82 countries – but one Jewish country is too many – that’s where I would agree with him only.
ZEV
-
Hillary Sodom Clinton and Barack Hussein Osama are both evil and both have good chances of winning.
John little-pants Edwards is evil and has little chance of winning. He also would not be a challenge for Republicans.
I think we should endorse John Edwards for Democrats.
I'm not up to date with jtf material, so this may have already been said.
-
Shalom Chaim,
I hope you are doing well, it has been awhile and I have been out of the loop as I have been really busy. My question to you is:
if islam did not teach Jew hatred and was not after Jewish blood but after the blood of everyone else like it currently is now, what would JTF's position on islam be?
Thank you for your time,
Mstislav
-
Dear Chaim,
Do you have any tips or suggestions on what I can say to my classmates(I'm a senior in high school) in order to convince them of how serious the situation we are in really is? Even though I would call them conservative, they just seem to be apathetic more than anything.
-
Shalom Chaim,
When Judaism speaks of "An eye for an eye.....", revenge is the concept that is extracted. However why isn't it considered the same thing as Justice and thought to mean that? Justice, means a trial, punishment and your own back for example, with compensation or any other penalty lawful by religion......thats kind of equal to revenge isn't?. I believe the idea of revenge, that most people consider, of hating the enemy expressed through violence or just speech, is silly because it just creates a vicious circle. One person is killed then due to revenge everybody else dies too and nothing is solved or at peace.
Thank You.
-
Shalom Chaim,
Do you think that we should rely on Jews before we rely on Gentiles? Do you feel that we must trust ourselves before outsiders? Rav Kahane had Jews that cared defend Jews who didnt, do you agree with this policy, and if not, why not?
Thank you,
Nolandforshalom
-
Dear Chaim,
My question is this, should Jewish Task Force support mentally ill people carrying guns? And not have a balanced view on self defence?
I am sorry once again I will not know you answer, hopefully someone will tell me. I am very restricted on any video or MP3 format.
Be well, and thank you.
-
Shalom Chaim,
I heard what you staid about Churchill being as bad as Hitler and i have to say that i disagree...
First of all you spoke of how the British military sunk jews on ships bound for Israel, and while that did happen it was not Churchill that gave those orders.. He very much wanted the jews to live in Israel and later down the track his actions proved this.
Secondly, you made a sweeping statement about how Churchill refused to bomb the railroad lines leading to the death camps. At what point of the war were you referring to, remembering they only had access to those areas you speak of until 1944/1945.. and fighter planes back then could only travel a small distance before having to refuel.
Chaim i know you mean well but the point to be remembered is that Churchill did control every facet of the political arena in Britain which at the time i agree was vehemently anti-semetic but when he was given the chance to put things right by the jews he did...
P.S Are there sources of Information that agree with your rough analysis on Churchill as bad a Hitler ?
From, Sergio
-
Lately, I have heard and read about this so called "Khazar theory" which states that Ashkenazi Jews are primarily descended from Khazarian converts to Judaism and that we're not really descended from the original ancient Israelite tribes. I find this notion absolutely preposterous on its face and find it completely offensive and see this as nothing more as neo-Nazi and black supremacist propaganda that was manufactured for the sole purpose of invalidating Zionism. What do you know about this topic and can you share with us the origin and motivation behind this theory? Thanks.
Daniel
-
Shalom Chaim,
What book of R' Meir Kahane would you recommend to read the most ?
Toda Raba!
Daniel:
It's Ashkenazi Jews that came up with this theory, the first one was an Israeli name Avraham Folak and later on Arthur Koestler made that theory a bit more famouse. The Nazis liked this theory because it solves the paradox of hating Jews and that Juses was a Jew. So now they use it as their propagnda.
-
Shalom Chaim
This is a very long question; nevertheless, it is imperative that it is addressed in some meaningful fashion.
It can be said that certain aspects of the JTF ideology are logically unsound because they descend into fallacies of association, specifically the bad company fallacy and the closely related reductio ad Hitlerum (reduction to Hitler or the Nazis).
1. JTF often attempts to delegitimize perceived enemies such as MLK or Barack Obama by emphasizing an association, however tenuous, to controversial groups such as communists, the Congressional black caucus, the Nation of Islam, or other black radicals.
This form of argumentation violates philosophical principles and reasoning. Below is an example of the accurate premises and the faulty conclusion that tends to be expressed over the duration of a show.
The Nation of Islam provided body guards and hosted speeches for MLK.
The Nation of Islam is a black supremacist organization.
Therefore, MLK supports black supremacy.
2. At times, JTF injects 'Hitler' or the 'Nazis' inappropriately in order to derail opposition by adding undue emotion, rhetoric and hyperbole to an argument. Reductio ad Hitlerum was derived by Chicago school thinker Leo Strauss in 1950. Though it often contains fallacies of association, it is more often used as a wrong direction fallacy or an ad hominem.
An example:
Hillary Clinton strongly favors socialist economic policies.
The Nazis strongly held these and similar beliefs that subsequently led to the murder of millions of people.
Hillary Clinton holds dangerous Nazi beliefs.
My overall point is that there are enough valid arguments that can be constructed against Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, or whomever. You inform people of many reasons, such as Hillary's remarks about Jews and her support for bombing the Serbs.
I am not suggesting that you abandon your principles or basic style. I am suggesting that for the sake of honesty, you may have to abandon certain features of argumentation of which you are accustomed if you want to more successfully get the message across. In such a scenario, critics will have to focus on the truthful things you are saying instead of pointing out the apparent flaws in your technique.
Todah
-
If Jews are not allowed to hunt. Are jews allowed to use mouse traps or other? What about mammal trapping?
-
How would a Kahanist government react more harshly towards a republication of the Stalags than towards even "normal" pornography?
Here's an excerpt of a New York Times article (http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/06/world/middleeast/06stalags.html?_r=2&oref=slogin&oref=slogin (http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/06/world/middleeast/06stalags.html?_r=2&oref=slogin&oref=slogin)) on the Stalags:
The books told perverse tales of captured American or British pilots being abused by sadistic female SS officers outfitted with whips and boots. The plot usually ended with the male protagonists taking revenge, by raping and killing their tormentors...the Stalags were a distinctly Israeli genre, created by Israeli publishers and penned by Israeli authors, although they had masqueraded as translations from English and were written in the first person as if they were genuine memoirs.
I ask because it seems as though they combine porn with a desecration of the memory of the Nazis' victims.
-
Hi Chaim, I know a few months ago you had an Israeli attorney working on gaining you entry into Israel. I was wondering what came of that and if their is still work being done on your behalf. Thanks so much.
-
Chaim,
We just had our second daughter. O0 She was born healthy and gorgeous, at 9lbs. Paraphrasing rabbi Kahane ZT"L, HY"D, in one of his speeches, we are repaying our debt to Hitler of 2 million Jewish babies. So you see, having dogs does not preclude one from having children ;)
You know, to one extent or other, I disagree with you on quite a few subjects, but one thing is for certain - I consider you a great man, a tzadik and a very lucky person because you have had the privilege to meet and to work for HaRav Kahane. I would like to ask you two things:
1) A blessing for my older daughter and for the newborn one.
2) A promise that you, this year, day after day, will do atmost to establish a family - this has to be your priority number 1 this year and I don't think you are very serious about fullfiling this goal - Israel is full of eligible single women.
I really wish you to live a FULL life and, one day, to hold your grandchildren in your house in a liberated and secure Israel,overlooking beautiful Judean mountains and fields. Get serious about it!
-
The Lubavitch website http://www.noahide.com/yeshu.htm (http://www.noahide.com/yeshu.htm) said and I quote:
The Talmud records sins of "Jesus the Nazarene":
He was sexually immoral, worshipped statues of stone (Sanhedrin 107b; Sotah 47a).
Does the Talmud say derogatory things about Jesus? It's OK if you'd rather not comment.