JTF.ORG Forum
General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: Lubab on February 20, 2007, 07:20:45 PM
-
I don't know about you guys but I think Chaim's set behind him when he does the video shows is very hard on the eyes. You got the computer, the flag which looks like its seen better days and the office desk.
How much would it cost to get him a nicer background that blocks out the computer and desk? Maybe a screen that has an Israeli flag on it.
I think it would go a long way towards JTF being taken more seriously.
Anyone know anything about getting a nice background for Chaim?
-
I agree - I have been thinking the same thing.
-
I think it goes to show that JTF is trying to build itself up and needs financial support. It also looks more homely as if what Chaim is saying, truly comes from the heart. :)
Then again a change would look more professional
-
I agree Hajar - Chiam's background should not look too slick - that would detract from his message - you are probably right.
I was thinking - just - "updated" somewhat. :)
-
For what it is worth, I'd suggest that Chaim and David invest in a pair of those clip on microphones, have someone control the screen, pop up things for JTF and VJA, and have the shows set in a living room setting. Perhaps a nice couch and chair to allow JTF to invite guests each week to discuss current events similar to like an Oprah, Dr. Phil or The View type show only, of course, right wing, professional and not of their continual "progressive" ignorance.... I'd say 1-3 cameras, 2-4 microphones and someones home would be ideal although there are many others who know far more than I do on this techno related areas. The outcome could be edited very easily to produce a very professional looking show with relative ease.
I'd also, perhaps suggest, if it is possible to somehow start an evening AM radio show. Perhaps contacting Joseph Farrah for some funding or support as he assisted Savage and numerous others looking to save Israel, Lebanon and America...so I am told..
I feel, personally, that the goal might be to attain the highest level of professionalism to allow wider marketability. It is usually always far easier to sell, market and promote something professional over something that one could pick apart as "extremism" or some fly by night operation...especially if one wishes to ever approach some of the more main stream Conservative mediums, hosts or operations...
This is the best I can offer other than blowing up the Knesset and Israel Supreme Court, of course while both are in session.....
My two cents...
-
For what it is worth, I'd suggest that Chaim and David invest in a pair of those clip on microphones, have someone control the screen, pop up things for JTF and VJA, and have the shows set in a living room setting. Perhaps a nice couch and chair to allow JTF to invite guests each week to discuss current events similar to like an Oprah, Dr. Phil or The View type show only, of course, right wing, professional and not of their continual "progressive" ignorance.... I'd say 1-3 cameras, 2-4 microphones and someones home would be ideal although there are many others who know far more than I do on this techno related areas. The outcome could be edited very easily to produce a very professional looking show with relative ease.
I'd also, perhaps suggest, if it is possible to somehow start an evening AM radio show. Perhaps contacting Joseph Farrah for some funding or support as he assisted Savage and numerous others looking to save Israel, Lebanon and America...so I am told..
I feel, personally, that the goal might be to attain the highest level of professionalism to allow wider marketability. It is usually always far easier to sell, market and promote something professional over something that one could pick apart as "extremism" or some fly by night operation...especially if one wishes to ever approach some of the more main stream Conservative mediums, hosts or operations...
This is the best I can offer other than blowing up the Knesset and Israel Supreme Court, of course while both are in session.....
My two cents...
Thats a great suggestion, why don't you mention it to Chaim Marzutra. It doesn't require much extra costs and is something that can easily be done. Plus it'll make it all the better.
-
For what it is worth, I'd suggest that Chaim and David invest in a pair of those clip on microphones, have someone control the screen, pop up things for JTF and VJA, and have the shows set in a living room setting. Perhaps a nice couch and chair to allow JTF to invite guests each week to discuss current events similar to like an Oprah, Dr. Phil or The View type show only, of course, right wing, professional and not of their continual "progressive" ignorance.... I'd say 1-3 cameras, 2-4 microphones and someones home would be ideal although there are many others who know far more than I do on this techno related areas. The outcome could be edited very easily to produce a very professional looking show with relative ease.
I'd also, perhaps suggest, if it is possible to somehow start an evening AM radio show. Perhaps contacting Joseph Farrah for some funding or support as he assisted Savage and numerous others looking to save Israel, Lebanon and America...so I am told..
I feel, personally, that the goal might be to attain the highest level of professionalism to allow wider marketability. It is usually always far easier to sell, market and promote something professional over something that one could pick apart as "extremism" or some fly by night operation...especially if one wishes to ever approach some of the more main stream Conservative mediums, hosts or operations...
This is the best I can offer other than blowing up the Knesset and Israel Supreme Court, of course while both are in session.....
My two cents...
I absolutely agree with this sentiment 100%. An air of professionalism lends credibility. While Chaim likes the idea that kids also like the "underground" look and feel of a lot of the videos, the kids are not the earth shakers and movers. They are rebellious kids who think that is cool. Sure they will be earth shakers tomorrow...but by then they will have grown out of a lot of that underground rebellious stage and will still consider something professionally done to be more legitimate.
Having a "talk show" like setting would do wonders. Having a two or three camera setup would also be great. Using Mini-DV or High Definition cameras would help tremendously in picture quality.
I listened again to the sound and Chaim was right. The sound is really not that bad. But the picture could most definitely be helped by using higher end cameras and by having professional lighting done.
-
Guys are we willing to put together some cash for this project so we can come to Chaim with the proposal and the money? We need to find out how much these improvements will cost.
Chaim will be reluctant to use the general contributions for asthetic purposes like this.
I think our best shot is if the money is raised from the start specifically for this purpose.
For what is worth I will pledge $50 for this.
-
Guys are we willing to put together some cash for this project so we can come to Chaim with the proposal and the money? We need to find out how much these improvements will cost.
Chaim will be reluctant to use the general contributions for asthetic purposes like this.
I think our best shot is if the money is raised from the start specifically for this purpose.
For what is worth I will pledge $50 for this.
As I said before - I would like to see Chiam's set updated - but would not like to see it look too "slick".
When I see the set on youtube - I wonder if the shows I'm watching are really old shows - I think that is in response to the set looking dated - I think small changes might make a big impact. I like the format of the show without all the glitz that can be a distraction.
I would pledge $25.00 to this project - whatever is decided.
-
I'll pledge $20.
Why not make a huge poster of Rabbi Kahane and put it behind Chaim? Use a picture of the Rabbi that includes the flag of Israel.
1) There's nothing 'slick' about it.
2) It will lend a bit of 'professionalism' to the show.
3) It won't cost that much.
4) It represents JTF.
-
Do you need a credit card or bank account to give the money, can you post it?
Scriabin, i don't mean to be at all negative and its a good idea BUT.... another face in the background may distract you from Chaim and first time viewers may not know who Rabbi Kahane is and it'll be confusing.
I think a neatly pressed flag of Israel, tidy background, maybe JTF sign.....may be ok.
-
If you don't have a bank account you can mail a money order to the address on the website. But I don't think JTF can accept foreign currency.
So what do we got now $95 or so? This will for sure pay for the microphone clips. Does everyone at least agree they should get those?
-
I'll give 25 dollars
-
Ok look,
You want to be professional but not so slick. I don't get the mentality of this. Have any of you ever been part of a real political campaign? Have any of you worked in the media?
Ok, whatever.
You want to do it on the cheap then I would suggest this:
Put Chaim in front of a Green Screen. In Post-production of the video you can then project whatever image you want behind Chaim. Put a DESK in front of the Green Screen. This will give Chaim the air of being a news anchor etc. or being like David Letterman etc. (If you are going for the latter effect then let Chaim also have a mic with a mini-mic stand that sits on the desk. Much like what he has now.)
You still need good lights. It ought to be a three-point lighting kit at a bare minimum.
You still need a good camera.
The costs are broken down below in generalities:
1. The cost of a green screen behind Chaim: a 6' x 6' green screen (which would be fine for Chaim's purposes costs roughly around $180.00
2. The cost of just one good Mini-DV Camera which is a Prosumer camera (In-between total professional and regular schmuck) is by brand:
Panasonic DVX-100b: $3,910.00
Canon XL2 : $4,400
(Don't even worry about Sony.)
If you go the High Definition Camera route:
Panasonic HVX200 :$7,000.00 (camera only)
JVC GYHD100 : About the same price range as the HVX200 (Better camera overall though.)
A BASIC three point lighting kit: Approx. anywhere from $1500 to $2,000.
Now, with that said, all of these things can be gotten cheaper...like on EBAY but you will still be paying a higher price tag than I think most of you were thinking. But hey....quality costs. You don't want the JTF looking like it is produced in the bargain basement.
Again...you have GOT to get better at dealing with anything concerning the media. And if you are going to play politics then you have GOT to play to win. Otherwise...what's the friggin point?
-
I like the attidude here but we need to get real with how much money we have to work with.
I think lighting is key. If you know where to find a set cheaper pls. let us know. The green screen is surprisingly cheap and I think would be worth it.
-
Ok look,
You want to be professional but not so slick. I don't get the mentality of this. Have any of you ever been part of a real political campaign? Have any of you worked in the media?
Ok, whatever.
You want to do it on the cheap then I would suggest this:
Put Chaim in front of a Green Screen. In Post-production of the video you can then project whatever image you want behind Chaim. Put a DESK in front of the Green Screen. This will give Chaim the air of being a news anchor etc. or being like David Letterman etc. (If you are going for the latter effect then let Chaim also have a mic with a mini-mic stand that sits on the desk. Much like what he has now.)
You still need good lights. It ought to be a three-point lighting kit at a bare minimum.
You still need a good camera.
The costs are broken down below in generalities:
1. The cost of a green screen behind Chaim: a 6' x 6' green screen (which would be fine for Chaim's purposes costs roughly around $180.00
2. The cost of just one good Mini-DV Camera which is a Prosumer camera (In-between total professional and regular schmuck) is by brand:
Panasonic DVX-100b: $3,910.00
Canon XL2 : $4,400
(Don't even worry about Sony.)
If you go the High Definition Camera route:
Panasonic HVX200 :$7,000.00 (camera only)
JVC GYHD100 : About the same price range as the HVX200 (Better camera overall though.)
A BASIC three point lighting kit: Approx. anywhere from $1500 to $2,000.
Now, with that said, all of these things can be gotten cheaper...like on EBAY but you will still be paying a higher price tag than I think most of you were thinking. But hey....quality costs. You don't want the JTF looking like it is produced in the bargain basement.
Again...you have GOT to get better at dealing with anything concerning the media. And if you are going to play politics then you have GOT to play to win. Otherwise...what's the friggin point?
Very good. You obviously know far more about this stuff than I do. Very good. You are one that should be consulted directly with. Good post...
-
I like the attidude here but we need to get real with how much money we have to work with.
I think lighting is key. If you know where to find a set cheaper pls. let us know. The green screen is surprisingly cheap and I think would be worth it.
Unless this movement is seriously WAAAAYYYY smaller than I thought, I would think that funds could be allocated for something worthwhile like this.
You have to consider...if you produce higher end shows, there will be a broader market. You will find more avenues to place those shows both on the Internet as well as possibly on Television. (Provided you are not advocating violence or something.)
In any case, I did find a company that sells lighting kits for somewhat cheaper than I mentioned.
Check out:
http://www.pclightingsystems.com/tungsten/tungsten.html
The 3600 Watt Indie Filmmaker Kit would do the trick nicely for Chaim's purposes and comes in with a price tag of $995.00 which includes UPS delivery. This is definitely cheaper than some other places I've found where the average price was what I quoted above...anywhere from $1500 to $2,000.
-
oooo i know this dude, who is selling his mini-dv camcorder, its a Samsung VP-D461 i think......and since he needs the money desperatly, he is selling it for around £150, which is about $239. If everyone chips in it'll be quite a managble price, right? Plus you'd get a much sharper and clearer picture.
Heyyy theres no need to BUY lighting! Just fit a halogen lamp, or very bright mobile lamp, with reflecting sides and backdoors to control the position of the light. .......the results could be rather cheapy or on the contrary, perfectly adequate. :D
About collecting money.......if i forwarded some money by post to a person living in England. Could they pay through their bank account or something.... ???
-
You COULD conceivably do what Sarah is talking about with lighting. But I think it is a poor substitute for a real lighting kit.
This is because you really do need to have a good Primary light, a good fill and a good background light.
Using regular light sources makes it hard to achieve this sometimes.
-
Please do not go to the trouble of buying the Samsung VP-D461. It is a consumer grade camera. No professional would use it for broadcasting.
-
Please do not go to the trouble of buying the Samsung VP-D461. It is a consumer grade camera. No professional would use it for broadcasting.
You're the expert :D
-
DawnTreader:
The problem is not that the movement is so small that it coudn't raise the money needed to do this.
The problem is that Kahanists by their nature are extremely idealistic and often are not so practical. They want to go straight to the goal even though sometimes you need to take a couple steps back to jump forward. So Chaim is reluctant to dedicate funds to this when it could be used to help families in Judea Samaria etc.
So we can either try to change the whole philosophy or we'll just need to do the best with the people we have here who realize the importance of this.
I think when we get the plan clear with prices and then an appeal for money on the general discussion board is in order. Then we bring the plan and the money to Chaim.
Sarah:
I think you should PM Jimmy about how to get the money over to JTF. He should really help you with that if you want to give.
-
Should we bid on this?
Lighting system for $275-looks good but I know nothing about it.
http://cgi.ebay.com/Complete-used-lighting-system-NO-RESERVE_W0QQitemZ330102677798QQcategoryZ29945QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem
-
I would say, do not bid on this set. For one thing, the seller does not say exactly how many lights comes with the set, nor what type they are from what I could see. Of course, I briefly glanced over it so I could have missed some of those details, but I don't think so.
I would think you should have a very definite statement of what type of lights you are buying, what their wattage is etc. and whether they come with any lighting stands or not.
(I did see that this one came with at least one stand. Still, without knowing what types of lights are being sold or how many come with the set, it's a dangerous deal.)
-
What does Chaim think of all this?
-
Chaim thinks the look that the show has now may attract some younger viewers who like the "underground look" but he remains open to ideas from people who know more than him about these things. Hear the end of this past week's ASKJTF.
-
I think the underground look works.
-
In my opinion, the underground look takes away from the marketability in that it caters to young and the rather unstable youths.... Perhaps there could be two show where one is professional and the other marketed to younger focus groups... ?
-
There is no question that the set needs a makeover. Not just the set. As much as I respect Chaim for his devotion to the Jewish nationalist cause, and him having served time in prison for the plight of Soviet Jews, I am not impressed with his public speaking abilities. The underground look sucks. He should also wear a suit and tie.
This is an example of a good set, and a good speaker:
http://hallindsey.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=131
-
There is no question that the set needs a makeover. Not just the set. As much as I respect Chaim for his devotion to the Jewish nationalist cause, and him having served time in prison for the plight of Soviet Jews, I am not impressed with his public speaking abilities. The underground look sucks. He should also wear a suit and tie.
This is an example of a good set, and a good speaker:
http://hallindsey.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=131
The thing that come across the screen when I see Chaim speak is the honesty of his message. I listened to him for years and always felt he was very sincere in his message however seeing him really brings that message home. Chaim in a suit on a buffed up set isn't going to make that message any better. Its seeing Chaim as an honest individual pretenses aside that generates interest in JTF. Honestly the fellow in the above link in the thousand dollar suit strikes me as a boring fat cat and sort of stuffy. I think for now Chaim and David should not change a thing.
-
There is no question that the set needs a makeover. Not just the set. As much as I respect Chaim for his devotion to the Jewish nationalist cause, and him having served time in prison for the plight of Soviet Jews, I am not impressed with his public speaking abilities. The underground look sucks. He should also wear a suit and tie.
This is an example of a good set, and a good speaker:
http://hallindsey.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=131
I disagree.
I think Chaim is an excellent public speaker.
His has a very human quality about him.
I find that lacking in public personalities today.
I think you are mistaken if you think people need to be all glossed and polished to get a message across.
Unless of course their message is one of self promotion.
-
I completely disagree. Usama bin Laden, Ayman al-Zawahiri, Layth al-Libi and all the rest of the al-Qaida media figures make second rate videos in caves with nothing more than microphones, old army cammo jackets, AK-47s and meaningless messages. Many people are attracted to their cause the world over from these cut rate productions. If they can still accomplish their media and recruiting efforts from caves while hiding from Coalition Forces then I think Chaim can sway many with simply his wit and his words standing before America and the flag of his nation.
-
I completely disagree. Usama bin Laden, Ayman al-Zawahiri, Layth al-Libi and all the rest of the al-Qaida media figures make second rate videos in caves with nothing more than microphones, old army cammo jackets, AK-47s and meaningless messages. Many people are attracted to their cause the world over from these cut rate productions. If they can still accomplish their media and recruiting efforts from caves while hiding from Coalition Forces then I think Chaim can sway many with simply his wit and his words standing before America and the flag of his nation.
Bin Laden has a media infastrucutre that makes what he does known to the world immeidately. Bin Laden also committed very visible attacks so he's already famous. The American media on the other hand deliberately works not give Chaim (lehavdil) a voice, and Chaim ben Pesach is not a household name yet.
-
I completely disagree. Usama bin Laden, Ayman al-Zawahiri, Layth al-Libi and all the rest of the al-Qaida media figures make second rate videos in caves with nothing more than microphones, old army cammo jackets, AK-47s and meaningless messages. Many people are attracted to their cause the world over from these cut rate productions. If they can still accomplish their media and recruiting efforts from caves while hiding from Coalition Forces then I think Chaim can sway many with simply his wit and his words standing before America and the flag of his nation.
Bin Laden has a media infastrucutre that makes what he does known to the world immeidately. Bin Laden also committed very visible attacks so he's already famous. The American media on the other hand deliberately works not give Chaim (lehavdil) a voice, and Chaim ben Pesach is not a household name yet.
Very true, but the technological infrastructure of as-Sahab is not too much more advanced than that of JTF. It is at least safe to say that what As-Sahab media has at it's disposal is not unobtainable by JTF. And I might add that JTF's web forums far surpass any jihadist forum so far as content goes.