JTF.ORG Forum

General Category => General Discussion => Topic started by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 21, 2010, 10:00:26 PM

Title: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 21, 2010, 10:00:26 PM
When you make chicken soup, do you prefer to use "kosher salt" or table salt?  Which makes for a better tasting soup, or is there no difference?  
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Lisa on December 21, 2010, 10:12:57 PM
I believe kosher salt is more potent that the table salt.  I guess it depends on your taste.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: TheViper on December 21, 2010, 10:13:41 PM
I thought all salt was kosher?
I know some salt that is kosher has larger sized grains than others
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 21, 2010, 10:20:40 PM
I thought all salt was kosher?
I know some salt that is kosher has larger sized grains than others

All salt is kosher, but the bigger-grained salt was nicknamed "kosher salt" because it's typically used to salt meat (which is done to make meat kosher) and is particularly good at that.    Table salt is also kosher.    The difference though is a food difference, not a difference in kashrut, whereby the table salt is processed and contains some iodine derivatives and its grains are smaller.   
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 21, 2010, 10:23:13 PM
I believe kosher salt is more potent that the table salt.  I guess it depends on your taste.

Thanks.   Probably the more potent will be better.

I've been to so many Shabbat tables now after 3+ years of being a single frum guy.  But I can't figure out how all these women make their soups!   I've had so many that taste incredible.  And when I ask the recipe they don't really say anything different than my own basic strategy.   When I make soup though it tastes too bland.   I think I need better (fresh) vegetables, more salt (I will try kosher salt), and I did read online that if you add spices at the very end and not just at the beginning that this helps a lot too.    Usually I put all my spices in at the beginning.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: muman613 on December 21, 2010, 10:45:01 PM
I believe kosher salt is more potent that the table salt.  I guess it depends on your taste.

Thanks.   Probably the more potent will be better.

I've been to so many Shabbat tables now after 3+ years of being a single frum guy.  But I can't figure out how all these women make their soups!   I've had so many that taste incredible.  And when I ask the recipe they don't really say anything different than my own basic strategy.   When I make soup though it tastes too bland.   I think I need better (fresh) vegetables, more salt (I will try kosher salt), and I did read online that if you add spices at the very end and not just at the beginning that this helps a lot too.    Usually I put all my spices in at the beginning.

Another good reason to make a Shidduch!

Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: IsraeliGovtAreKapos on December 21, 2010, 10:46:22 PM
I believe kosher salt is more potent that the table salt.  I guess it depends on your taste.

Thanks.   Probably the more potent will be better.

I've been to so many Shabbat tables now after 3+ years of being a single frum guy.  But I can't figure out how all these women make their soups!   I've had so many that taste incredible.  And when I ask the recipe they don't really say anything different than my own basic strategy.   When I make soup though it tastes too bland.   I think I need better (fresh) vegetables, more salt (I will try kosher salt), and I did read online that if you add spices at the very end and not just at the beginning that this helps a lot too.    Usually I put all my spices in at the beginning.

Lol women
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Lisa on December 21, 2010, 10:59:24 PM
I read in the Book "Nourishing Traditions" by Sally Fallon that Jewish women in the past would use parts such as chicken feet for their soups.  The idea being that you need to use bones to make a great broth. 
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 21, 2010, 11:16:06 PM
I believe kosher salt is more potent that the table salt.  I guess it depends on your taste.

Thanks.   Probably the more potent will be better.

I've been to so many Shabbat tables now after 3+ years of being a single frum guy.  But I can't figure out how all these women make their soups!   I've had so many that taste incredible.  And when I ask the recipe they don't really say anything different than my own basic strategy.   When I make soup though it tastes too bland.   I think I need better (fresh) vegetables, more salt (I will try kosher salt), and I did read online that if you add spices at the very end and not just at the beginning that this helps a lot too.    Usually I put all my spices in at the beginning.

Another good reason to make a Shidduch!


 
 
;D  hahah

You make a good point.   But I really want to learn to cook well myself too.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 21, 2010, 11:17:59 PM
I believe kosher salt is more potent that the table salt.  I guess it depends on your taste.

Thanks.   Probably the more potent will be better.

I've been to so many Shabbat tables now after 3+ years of being a single frum guy.  But I can't figure out how all these women make their soups!   I've had so many that taste incredible.  And when I ask the recipe they don't really say anything different than my own basic strategy.   When I make soup though it tastes too bland.   I think I need better (fresh) vegetables, more salt (I will try kosher salt), and I did read online that if you add spices at the very end and not just at the beginning that this helps a lot too.    Usually I put all my spices in at the beginning.

Lol women

L'heetanayg b'tanoogeem!   To make the food taste great is a valuable skill, Ron.  It's not easy.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 21, 2010, 11:19:27 PM
I read in the Book "Nourishing Traditions" by Sally Fallon that Jewish women in the past would use parts such as chicken feet for their soups.  The idea being that you need to use bones to make a great broth. 

Oh.   I sometimes use cut up chicken pieces and other times I use boneless chicken breasts, I guess the chicken with the skin and the bones probably give more flavor.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Ari Ben-Canaan on December 21, 2010, 11:32:36 PM
Kosher salt [large grained] is usually used in larger quantities because there is more airspace between particles.  Chefs prefer it because it is easier to weigh out by hand [as it is more visually assessable].  I believe Alton Brown, a master chef [imo] on Food Network has proven that it mixes into water easier than regular salt does [although smaller grained salt is preferable if cooking something where enough water to dissolve salt is not appropriate].  For most recipes I think a 2:1 ratio for "Kosher style" salt vs. small grained salt is appropriate [often times the Kosher salt container will list a ratio for their product].

I make all of my soups from scratch.  I have found the spice blend called, "Hawajj" [Yemeni origin], really adds a tremendous boost of flavor.  I also add a bit of ground cayenne for kick.  I like to use peas in my soup to thicken it up [make sure to check the dates on the bag of peas; older peas mineralize and will not take on water, making the peas only slightly soft and partially hard regardless of how long you cook the peas for...  very unpleasant to eat][lentils are also another good addition; after all they are what Esau traded his legacy to Jacob for!].  Also, instant potatoes can be added in the soup process to suck up any unwanted water if making a thicker stew is your goal [the flakes work to thicken something up in mere seconds!][check the hescher on the potatoes, often sold in flake form; some have dairy added to them...  my "Idahoan" brand flakes are certified Parve by Orthodox Union][flour can be used to thicken up a soup if you do not have potato flakes but I usually leave that to thicken up a sauce if a sauce I am making is too watery at the end].

Usually I cut up onions, carrots, sometimes celery, and garlic and toss them into the water early [as well as all spices including salt and pepper] on to season the water [which will be soaked up by peas/rice/whatever else you put into your soup].  When mincing garlic, after chopping the garlic up to some degree I add a pinch of small grained salt to the garlic because it really helps break the garlic down during the mincing process and lets you get the garlic into very tiny pieces [take the amount of salt you add to the garlic in consideration to the total amount of salt you add to your recipe].

http://www.grouprecipes.com/76416/hawaij-spice-blend.html

Here is a link to some info on the Hawajj and how to concoct it from ordinary spices.

"Baharat" is another spice blend I use.  It is on the other end of the taste spectrum than the Hawajj.  Sweeter.  Its great on vegetables, but can also be used to make a good soup.  I recommend using it on veggies first to get a taste for the Baharat stuff and then try it out in soups if a good soup is what you wish to create. -- The Hawajj stuff is pretty forgiving to cook with so I recommend it to try out first.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 21, 2010, 11:41:15 PM
Funny you mention hawayej, that's the secret ingredient to the Teymani Soup which Yemenite Jews have as their traditional friday night meal.  This is the best soup I have ever tasted.  I was planning on trying out making Yemenite Soup after I perfected the chicken soup.    Making a fresh hawaij is a key to the Yemenite soup from what I've read.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 21, 2010, 11:43:33 PM
what are potato flakes?
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Ari Ben-Canaan on December 21, 2010, 11:47:43 PM
Funny you mention hawayej, that's the secret ingredient to the Teymani Soup which Yemenite Jews have as their traditional friday night meal.  This is the best soup I have ever tasted.  I was planning on trying out making Yemenite Soup after I perfected the chicken soup.    Making a fresh hawaij is a key to the Yemenite soup from what I've read.

Indeed!  My studies of Yemeni culture led me to the Hawajj.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Ari Ben-Canaan on December 21, 2010, 11:51:11 PM
what are potato flakes?

I believe most 'instant potatoes' are compromised of potato flakes.  I am not sure if all instant potatoes are made of this, only all the ones I have bought since I have started to cook.  You can also use actual mashed potatoes to thicken up a soup as well, if you have them laying around from a previous meal it is an ideal way to keep your kitchen pumping out the goods w/o waste.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: HiWarp on December 22, 2010, 08:51:31 AM
If your soup is too bland, you are simply not using enough salt. Period. If you had said that the soup lacked the rich flavor you had tasted in other people's soups, then that would be different.

Here's what I've picked up when making soups, for what it's worth.

Simmer, simmer, simmer the chicken (or whatever else you're using) and vegetables to make a rich, flavorful stock. When you are done simmering them, simmer them some more. I have done this to the point where I have reduced the amount of liquid by 1/3 the total volume.

Then, let it cool and refrigerate it overnight, with the chicken and vegetables still in the pot.

The following day, strain the liquid and make your soup. This will get you a very flavorful soup but, if you don't add the proper amount of salt, it will always be bland.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: angryChineseKahanist on December 22, 2010, 10:29:11 AM

I prefer sea salt. It doesn't have aluminum compounds added.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Boyana on December 22, 2010, 10:45:39 AM
This makes my soup famous and delicious



http://www.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=http://profile.ak.fbcdn.net/hprofile-ak-snc4/hs846.snc4/71

It is made in Serbia.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 22, 2010, 01:47:06 PM
If your soup is too bland, you are simply not using enough salt. Period. If you had said that the soup lacked the rich flavor you had tasted in other people's soups, then that would be different.   

Well, it's both :)


Quote
Here's what I've picked up when making soups, for what it's worth.

Simmer, simmer, simmer the chicken (or whatever else you're using) and vegetables to make a rich, flavorful stock. When you are done simmering them, simmer them some more. I have done this to the point where I have reduced the amount of liquid by 1/3 the total volume.

Then, let it cool and refrigerate it overnight, with the chicken and vegetables still in the pot.

The following day, strain the liquid and make your soup. This will get you a very flavorful soup but, if you don't add the proper amount of salt, it will always be bland.

Thanks.

What do you mean by "strain the liquid and make your soup"  ?    Wasn't the thing you left overnight the soup?   What liquid do you strain?
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 22, 2010, 01:48:21 PM
This makes my soup famous and delicious



http://www.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=http://profile.ak.fbcdn.net/hprofile-ak-snc4/hs846.snc4/71

It is made in Serbia.

It seems that link is not working.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Lisa on December 22, 2010, 08:29:11 PM
KWRBT, here's what I think he means by straining the soup. 

When you make soup, and then refrigerate it overnight, a layer of fat will form overnight.  When you go to reheat the soup, simply spoon off the layer of fat, and you have low fat soup.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: cjd on December 22, 2010, 10:34:11 PM
KWRBT, here's what I think he means by straining the soup. 

When you make soup, and then refrigerate it overnight, a layer of fat will form overnight.  When you go to reheat the soup, simply spoon off the layer of fat, and you have low fat soup.
I find getting rid of the excess fat in this way is a a must for Matzoh Ball Soup... It keeps the Matzoh balls from absorbing to much of the chicken fat.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Lisa on December 22, 2010, 10:56:40 PM
I like hard matzo balls!   ;D ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: JTFenthusiast2 on December 22, 2010, 11:07:28 PM
I like hard matzo balls!   ;D ;D ;D ;D

Yeah when they are soft, they are too 'mealy'  BTW, I never had warm gefilte fish before.  I really like it cold.  Warm, I felt like I wanted to puke
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: muman613 on December 22, 2010, 11:10:56 PM
(http://coloradoguy.com/new-york-city/matzo-ball-soup.jpg)
THATS A spicy Matzoh Ball!!
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Ari Ben-Canaan on December 22, 2010, 11:18:43 PM
(http://coloradoguy.com/new-york-city/matzo-ball-soup.jpg)
THATS A spicy Matzoh Ball!!

That looks great.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: HiWarp on December 23, 2010, 06:51:51 AM
KWRBT, here's what I think he means by straining the soup. 

When you make soup, and then refrigerate it overnight, a layer of fat will form overnight.  When you go to reheat the soup, simply spoon off the layer of fat, and you have low fat soup.

That is partly what I mean. Removing the coagulated fat from the top is a must (unless you like greasy, fatty soup). However, remember I said to leave the liquid, chicken and vegetables in the pot overnight. So the other part of it is to use a strainer to catch all the solid stuff and retain only the liquid. As for whether or not that is the soup, actually what you have there is chicken broth. If you want to only have clear chicken broth as your soup, then you are done. However, you can add vegetables, rice, noodles, etc...really whatever you like to "make the soup". It's totally up to you. If you add additional items, the soup only needs to cook long enough to cook those items since it already has all the flavor it needs.

One other thing that I should clarify. When you cook the chicken in the pot, use a chicken carcass because you will be cooking the liquid for hours. If you cook the whole chicken and then plan to add some of the meat in your final soup, the meat will probably be a little tough. What I actually like to do is roast a chicken, have a nice chicken dinner, remove most of the remaining meat, then make the chicken broth with the carcass and use the remaining meat in the final soup.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on December 23, 2010, 03:00:13 PM
KWRBT, here's what I think he means by straining the soup. 

When you make soup, and then refrigerate it overnight, a layer of fat will form overnight.  When you go to reheat the soup, simply spoon off the layer of fat, and you have low fat soup.

That is partly what I mean. Removing the coagulated fat from the top is a must (unless you like greasy, fatty soup). However, remember I said to leave the liquid, chicken and vegetables in the pot overnight. So the other part of it is to use a strainer to catch all the solid stuff and retain only the liquid. As for whether or not that is the soup, actually what you have there is chicken broth. If you want to only have clear chicken broth as your soup, then you are done. However, you can add vegetables, rice, noodles, etc...really whatever you like to "make the soup". It's totally up to you. If you add additional items, the soup only needs to cook long enough to cook those items since it already has all the flavor it needs.

One other thing that I should clarify. When you cook the chicken in the pot, use a chicken carcass because you will be cooking the liquid for hours. If you cook the whole chicken and then plan to add some of the meat in your final soup, the meat will probably be a little tough. What I actually like to do is roast a chicken, have a nice chicken dinner, remove most of the remaining meat, then make the chicken broth with the carcass and use the remaining meat in the final soup.

Thanks, great advice!

When you strain out all the solid stuff, but then add new fresh vegetables and cook them in the broth, what do you do with the original solid vegetables etc?   You don't eat them?
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: HiWarp on January 02, 2011, 06:52:18 AM
KWRBT, here's what I think he means by straining the soup. 

When you make soup, and then refrigerate it overnight, a layer of fat will form overnight.  When you go to reheat the soup, simply spoon off the layer of fat, and you have low fat soup.

That is partly what I mean. Removing the coagulated fat from the top is a must (unless you like greasy, fatty soup). However, remember I said to leave the liquid, chicken and vegetables in the pot overnight. So the other part of it is to use a strainer to catch all the solid stuff and retain only the liquid. As for whether or not that is the soup, actually what you have there is chicken broth. If you want to only have clear chicken broth as your soup, then you are done. However, you can add vegetables, rice, noodles, etc...really whatever you like to "make the soup". It's totally up to you. If you add additional items, the soup only needs to cook long enough to cook those items since it already has all the flavor it needs.

One other thing that I should clarify. When you cook the chicken in the pot, use a chicken carcass because you will be cooking the liquid for hours. If you cook the whole chicken and then plan to add some of the meat in your final soup, the meat will probably be a little tough. What I actually like to do is roast a chicken, have a nice chicken dinner, remove most of the remaining meat, then make the chicken broth with the carcass and use the remaining meat in the final soup.

Thanks, great advice!

When you strain out all the solid stuff, but then add new fresh vegetables and cook them in the broth, what do you do with the original solid vegetables etc?   You don't eat them?

No, toss them in the garbage. They have faithfully given up their lives for the greater good of the soup.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: Kahane-Was-Right BT on January 02, 2011, 10:57:52 AM
KWRBT, here's what I think he means by straining the soup. 

When you make soup, and then refrigerate it overnight, a layer of fat will form overnight.  When you go to reheat the soup, simply spoon off the layer of fat, and you have low fat soup.

That is partly what I mean. Removing the coagulated fat from the top is a must (unless you like greasy, fatty soup). However, remember I said to leave the liquid, chicken and vegetables in the pot overnight. So the other part of it is to use a strainer to catch all the solid stuff and retain only the liquid. As for whether or not that is the soup, actually what you have there is chicken broth. If you want to only have clear chicken broth as your soup, then you are done. However, you can add vegetables, rice, noodles, etc...really whatever you like to "make the soup". It's totally up to you. If you add additional items, the soup only needs to cook long enough to cook those items since it already has all the flavor it needs.

One other thing that I should clarify. When you cook the chicken in the pot, use a chicken carcass because you will be cooking the liquid for hours. If you cook the whole chicken and then plan to add some of the meat in your final soup, the meat will probably be a little tough. What I actually like to do is roast a chicken, have a nice chicken dinner, remove most of the remaining meat, then make the chicken broth with the carcass and use the remaining meat in the final soup.

Thanks, great advice!

When you strain out all the solid stuff, but then add new fresh vegetables and cook them in the broth, what do you do with the original solid vegetables etc?   You don't eat them?

No, toss them in the garbage. They have faithfully given up their lives for the greater good of the soup.

Ha!   

Got it.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: angryChineseKahanist on January 02, 2011, 07:49:43 PM
Is sea salt kosher?
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: cjd on January 02, 2011, 07:55:50 PM
Is sea salt kosher?

I believe sea salt can be kosher but it has to be processed correctly in order to be so.
Title: Re: To the chefs of JTF - chicken soup - Kosher salt or Table salt?
Post by: angryChineseKahanist on January 02, 2011, 08:49:00 PM
How did they kosherfy salt in the days before technology?