Author Topic: Obama is Machiavellian, not naive  (Read 794 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Madeline

  • Full JTFer
  • ***
  • Posts: 118
Obama is Machiavellian, not naive
« on: June 20, 2008, 07:17:40 AM »
Here's a thoughtful article from a writer that is usually more center of right than right, but what he says here rings true for me.  Obama is really slick, or as Pastor Manning likes to say, He's a Mack Daddy.  Watch Obama next time he's on stage with his wife, the way he pushes her here and there in a carefully orchestrated 'spontaneous' choreography.  He's using the mask of naivite to cover up complex political calculalations, including a vagueness that liberates him from accountability.  Naive is a little like stupid, right?  And what do most people, including blacks, think about their intelligence?  Not the best, right?  So it's easy for him to get away with seeming a little bit 'stupid' and still have so many people pulling for him, trying to do their affirmative action best.  Furthermore, naive is supposed to be kind of harmless.  Won't we be surprised if he and his wife get into the White House and turn it into a stick-it-to-Whitey enterprise!  And that is the whole point of his racist

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/20/opinion/20brooks.html?_r=1&ref=opinion&oref=slogin

THE TWO OBAMAS
 
By DAVID BROOKS
Published: June 20, 2008
God, Republicans are saps. They think that they’re running against some academic liberal who wouldn’t wear flag pins on his lapel, whose wife isn’t proud of America and who went to some liberationist church where the pastor damned his own country. They think they’re running against some naïve university-town dreamer, the second coming of Adlai Stevenson.

But as recent weeks have made clear, Barack Obama is the most split-personality politician in the country today. On the one hand, there is Dr. Barack, the high-minded, Niebuhr-quoting speechifier who spent this past winter thrilling the Scarlett Johansson set and feeling the fierce urgency of now. But then on the other side, there’s Fast Eddie Obama, the promise-breaking, tough-minded Chicago pol who’d throw you under the truck for votes.

This guy is the whole Chicago package: an idealistic, lakefront liberal fronting a sharp-elbowed machine operator. He’s the only politician of our lifetime who is underestimated because he’s too intelligent. He speaks so calmly and polysyllabically that people fail to appreciate the Machiavellian ambition inside.

But he’s been giving us an education, for anybody who cares to pay attention. Just try to imagine Mister Rogers playing the agent Ari in “Entourage” and it all falls into place.

Back when he was in the Illinois State Senate, Dr. Barack could have taken positions on politically uncomfortable issues. But Fast Eddie Obama voted “present” nearly 130 times. From time to time, he threw his voting power under the truck.

Dr. Barack said he could no more disown the Rev. Jeremiah Wright than disown his own grandmother. Then the political costs of Rev. Wright escalated and Fast Eddie Obama threw Wright under the truck.

Dr. Barack could have been a workhorse senator. But primary candidates don’t do tough votes, so Fast Eddie Obama threw the workhorse duties under the truck.

Dr. Barack could have changed the way presidential campaigning works. John McCain offered to have a series of extended town-hall meetings around the country. But favored candidates don’t go in for unscripted free-range conversations. Fast Eddie Obama threw the new-politics mantra under the truck.

And then on Thursday, Fast Eddie Obama had his finest hour. Barack Obama has worked on political reform more than any other issue. He aspires to be to political reform what Bono is to fighting disease in Africa. He’s spent much of his career talking about how much he believes in public financing. In January 2007, he told Larry King that the public-financing system works. In February 2007, he challenged Republicans to limit their spending and vowed to do so along with them if he were the nominee. In February 2008, he said he would aggressively pursue spending limits. He answered a Midwest Democracy Network questionnaire by reminding everyone that he has been a longtime advocate of the public-financing system.

But Thursday, at the first breath of political inconvenience, Fast Eddie Obama threw public financing under the truck. In so doing, he probably dealt a death-blow to the cause of campaign-finance reform. And the only thing that changed between Thursday and when he lauded the system is that Obama’s got more money now.

And Fast Eddie Obama didn’t just sell out the primary cause of his life. He did it with style. He did it with a video so risibly insincere that somewhere down in the shadow world, Lee Atwater is gaping and applauding. Obama blamed the (so far marginal) Republican 527s. He claimed that private donations are really public financing. He made a cut-throat political calculation seem like Mother Teresa’s final steps to sainthood.

The media and the activists won’t care (they were only interested in campaign-finance reform only when the Republicans had more money). Meanwhile, Obama’s money is forever. He’s got an army of small donors and a phalanx of big money bundlers, including, according to The Washington Post, Kenneth Griffin of the Citadel Investment Group; Kirk Wager, a Florida trial lawyer; James Crown, a director of General Dynamics; and Neil Bluhm, a hotel, office and casino developer.

I have to admit, I’m ambivalent watching all this. On the one hand, Obama did sell out the primary cause of his professional life, all for a tiny political advantage. If he’ll sell that out, what won’t he sell out? On the other hand, global affairs ain’t beanbag. If we’re going to have a president who is going to go toe to toe with the likes of Vladimir Putin, maybe it is better that he should have a ruthlessly opportunist Fast Eddie Obama lurking inside.

All I know for sure is that this guy is no liberal goo-goo. Republicans keep calling him naïve. But naïve is the last word I’d use to describe Barack Obama. He’s the most effectively political creature we’ve seen in decades. Even Bill Clinton wasn’t smart enough to succeed in politics by pretending to renounce politics.


Offline dvir

  • New JTFer
  • *
  • Posts: 21
Re: Obama is Machiavellian, not naive
« Reply #1 on: June 22, 2008, 03:54:50 AM »
Chalila/G-d forbid. Nobama is too inconsistent.

This web page is a good P.S. in the context of David Brooks' article:

http://hotair.com/archives/2008/06/21/mark-shields-obama-couldnt-pass-a-polygraph/

How much more of this "schizophrenic" nonsense will allowed before people with common sense notice?
People are noticing already.


For example, in a Memorial Day speech (documented on Michelle Malkin's website), he began a sentence talking about Memorial Day and by mid-sentence he thought he was talking about Veterans Day: 

"On this Memorial Day, as our nation honors its unbroken line of fallen heroes — and I see many of them in the audience here today — our sense of patriotism is particularly strong."

How far away from reality can "charisma" take us? Not that far.


As for the famous "Selma" speech:

http://hotair.com/archives/2007/03/05/audio-hillary-obama-develop-southern-accents-for-selma/

Barack Obama Sr.'s arrival at the University of Hawaii in 1959 had nothing to do with:

1. Birmingham, Alabama
2. Selma, Alabama
3. "folks in the White House"
4. "battling Communism"
5. John Kennedy
6. "the Kennedy's"

A Kenyan leader, Tom Mboya, funded Obama Sr.'s trip to the U.S. That is 6 mistakes in one paragraph.

Obama was not born "because of what happened in Selma, Alabama" as he claimed in the speech.

Barack Obama Jr. was born August 4, 1961.
The Bloody Sunday march across the Edmund Pettus Bridge was on March 7, 1965.

How far from reality can "metaphorically speaking" take us? Not that far.


All the "smoke" will clear. All the "mirrors" will be broken.


"What distinguishes prayer and sacrifice from all magic? - Magic desires to obtain its effects without entering into relation, and practices its tricks in the void. But sacrifice and prayer are set 'Before the Face,' . . . " - Martin Buber ("I and Thou", 1923)

Say T'hilim for Israel and America.

Ci col elohei ha amim elilim (pause) va ' ' shamaim asa.
For all the gods of the peoples are nothings - but Hashem made the heavens.
Divrei Ha Yamim I 16:26


dvir