Do "Israeli Arabs" go to the Army in Israel?

[Raulmarrio2000]

Do "Israeli Arabs" go to the Army in Israel? I suppose not.
Of cousre it would a madness to let them into IDF, but if they want their citizenship or residence, they should do some National Service outside the Army, and the same would apply to Palis in Yesha.
Just make them work for Israel for 3 years. I think they'd voluntarily leave the country, and noone can say Israel is unfair to them. In most countries if you refuse national service you are not even allowed to leave, you are either taken to prison or even executed for treason.
In Argentina, when there was National Service, everyone who deserted was taken to prison, no chance to go abroad.

[Eliezer Ben Avraham]

Druze do.

[Raulmarrio2000]

Yes, Druze are loyal to Israel as far as I know. There was a special Druze unit in IDF. It was very used by Shamir Govt to repress the first Intifada, since many Jewish soldiers refused to fight with "helpless palis"

But I think Arabs in Israel and Palis would flee if they had to work free for Israel, knowing that their work is to support IDF!!!!!

[Eliezer Ben Avraham]

Yes, Druze are loyal to Israel as far as I know. There was a special Druze unit in IDF. It was very used by Shamir Govt to repress the first Intifada, since many Jewish soldiers refused to fight with "helpless palis"

But I think Arabs in Israel and Palis would flee if they had to work free for Israel, knowing that their work is to support IDF!!!!!

Some bedouins are ok too. We don't need enemies in our own army, enemies belong in their own countries, we can't fight enemy from within

[Raulmarrio2000]

I never said that they must be in the Army. I just say that they should be forced to do some work for the country instead. Some other service to conpensate Israel for not being in the Army while Jews are. For example having to give the product of their work to IDF during 3 years. Surely they'd leave!!! They won't support IDF!!!

[Raulmarrio2000]

For example, when an Arab in the age a Jew is in tha army, is working for himself. Just make him give his wage to the iDF. That would be enough. They cannot poison money!

[Raulmarrio2000]

An Arab boy between 18 and 21 would not necessarily starve for giving his wages to IDF. But surely he won't!!! And he may leave. Especially if he had to sign soemthing like this when paying the tax: " I, an Arab Resident in the Land of Israel which belongs to the Israelites, hereby pay my wages to the army which defends this country. By this I fullfill my duty with Natinal Service, as the Ezrachim do by serving in IDF. I swear fidelity to Eretz Yisrael as a Jewsih country forever. I will respect Jewish rights on it, and especially on Jerusalem, its eternal capital. I solemnly swear that I will never deny Jewish rights, even when if I leave Israel. So I beg to be considered a legal resident while Israeli Law allows me to stay"
Do you think any Arabs could endure this?

[Ehud]

Actually just recently (can't remember how long, around 4 months ago) there was a proposal for mandatory social service for arabs.  It was something like, they have to perform 2 years of mandatory social service (they can do it within their own communities if they want) or else they'll lose their right to vote.  I think it's a step in the right direction but it's not good enough.  I think that if this plan was implemented, the arabs' descendants should lose their voting rights as well.  Of course much of this "social service" would be raising money for Hamas, funding terrorists, but I think it would be better if the arabs were involved with helping their communities in some way because then they would be distracted a bit.

Almost no arabs would endure having to make a statement like that, Raul. 

[Raulmarrio2000]

That's my point. There won't endure it and will leave, or at least lose their right to vote. Here in Argentina, any foreigner who wants to be Agentinian is forced to swear something similar. Why not in Israel?

[mord]

Circcasians also do they are from the Caucassas they are nice clean friendly people