raiseyourfist: "...What does everyone think about this idea that JDL implemented some years ago?..."
During that time, insane Jews all over the U.S. denounced JDL as vigilante terrorists & hooligans.
If the "neighborhood watch" gangs were resurrected today, everyone would be immediately arrested and charged with terrorism and probably a dozen other felony charges.
Foxman & the ACLU would join Jackson & Sharpton everywhere in the media demanding that the courts give the "Jewish hoodlums" the maximum sentence possible.
If Bush denounced the Minutemen as "racists" from the White House merely for guarding America's southernmost border, what do you think would happen the very first time an altercation took place in the act of defending Jewish life and/or property?
But I like the idea very much other than for those reasons.