How did you change the title of the thread?
I am not anti-Semitic. I am Jewish. I am not a Nazi, Heavens Forbid. I had relatives gassed during the Holocaust.
I stand by my opinion that a scholar should be judged by his scholarship.
By the way, there is a debate between a Jewish writer for
www.Jewcy.com and John Derbyshire, a writer for
National Review who reviewed
The Culture of Critique in
The American Conservative (
www.amconmag.com). The Jewish writer says there is truth to MacDonald's ideas; Derbyshire says there is a lot of falsehood also.
By the way, MacDonald's website is
www.csulb.edu/~kmacd.
I know that posters on this site are against multiculturalism and for preserving the white Christian majorities where it exists. It's undoubtable that Jews played a disproportionate role in bringing about this situation, but they are not the sole cause, and they can reform themselves. Nor is Judaism monolithic.
Lawrence Auster (
www.amnation.com/vfr) and Stephen Steinlight have written about the Jewish role in liberal immigration policies, and they're both Jewish, I think Jews like us need criticism and can use reading well reasoned arguments by non-Jews on the Jewish role in destroying traditional western societies.