Nuking Mecca

[Norman]

I personally think they both should. Chaim thinks it's not practical for Israel to do this. I think it would be practical for Israel to do this if the world were united in confronting Islam.

[Allen-T]

I think both should but not for vengeance per se, but simply to put that filthy religion out of business. Send them, as Rabbi Friedman would say, "special MD's to heal them, WMDs!!"

[Norman]

Thanks Allen. I took the vengeance part out of the question.

[Dr. Dan]

I personally think they both should. Chaim thinks it's not practical for Israel to do this. I think it would be practical for Israel to do this if the world were united in confronting Islam.

I agree wtih Chaim though..Nuclear fallout is not a good thing for the earth either...it's not as simple as opening a candy wrapper.  It depends on the threat.

[MassuhDGoodName]

Plan B for Mecca (by MassuhD)

1.  Overfly Mecca during the Haj with giant planes, all spraying tons of LSD / PCP aerosol down on the insect multitudes.

2.  Immediately follow with overflights dropping millions of sabres, knives, and loaded hand guns, down on the insects below.

3.  Then, hundreds of hologram / microwave thought-inducing planes fly over Mecca, beaming down the frantic call-to-arms telepathic messages such as...

"ZIONISTS!"...."THEY ARE HERE!"...."EVERYWHERE!"...."KILL THEM!"...."TRUST NOONE!"..."THERE, BEHIND YOU!"...."THERE'S ANOTHER INFIDEL...KILL HIM!"...."JIHAD!"...."JIHAD!"...."AMERICAN AGENTS OF BUSH ARE SEIZING THE QA'ABA!"....."KILL THEM!"

4.  Run!

[Shlomo]

You remembered one of my FAVORITE topics!! LOL

Wait until it's full... then drop a neutron bomb on it. Then use that rock to make toilets for the new building that replaces the twin towers.

What a wonderful plan!

You knew I'd respond to this, didn't you?

[MarZutra]

I think Israel should.  The reason for this is that it must be....literally....a light among the nations.  Give this world something really to complain about.  Blame them and later thank them...  I'd like to see Israel take out Damascus, Tehran, Mecca while America takes out Moscow, Beijing, Havana while India nukes Pakistan...  Lets get it on!!

[Nic Brookes]

Plan B for Mecca (by MassuhD)

1.  Overfly Mecca during the Haj with giant planes, all spraying tons of LSD / PCP aerosol down on the insect multitudes.

2.  Immediately follow with overflights dropping millions of sabres, knives, and loaded hand guns, down on the insects below.

3.  Then, hundreds of hologram / microwave thought-inducing planes fly over Mecca, beaming down the frantic call-to-arms telepathic messages such as...

"ZIONISTS!"...."THEY ARE HERE!"...."EVERYWHERE!"...."KILL THEM!"...."TRUST NOONE!"..."THERE, BEHIND YOU!"...."THERE'S ANOTHER INFIDEL...KILL HIM!"...."JIHAD!"...."JIHAD!"...."AMERICAN AGENTS OF BUSH ARE SEIZING THE QA'ABA!"....."KILL THEM!"

4.  Run!

Pure genius

[judeanoncapta]

There is an ancient apochryphal jewish text from the year 400 ce that predicts the burning of Mecca in the end of days. It's called that prophecy of the child Nevuat HaYeled. Maybe it's on to something.

[jdl4ever]

Let Israel nuke it and blame it on the Kahanists (say a lone Kahanist nuclear defense contractor did it).  We'll be happy to take the blame for such a sanctification of G-d's name! 

[Shlomo]

I think Israel should.  The reason for this is that it must be....literally....a light among the nations.  Give this world something really to complain about.  Blame them and later thank them...  I'd like to see Israel take out Damascus, Tehran, Mecca while America takes out Moscow, Beijing, Havana while India nukes Pakistan...  Lets get it on!!

Brilliant!

Wouldn't that be something!

What about China, though?

[Carlyle]

Tom Tancredo says: "We could nuke Mecca"

Freepers discuss:
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-backroom/1443646/posts

[Scriabin]

I think Israel should.  The reason for this is that it must be....literally....a light among the nations.  Give this world something really to complain about.  Blame them and later thank them...  I'd like to see Israel take out Damascus, Tehran, Mecca while America takes out Moscow, Beijing, Havana while India nukes Pakistan...  Lets get it on!!

Brilliant!

Wouldn't that be something!

What about China, though?

We're kidding ourselves if we think we can take China.

The WWII generation is no more.  We've become fat, lazy, stupid, selfish children.

For all intents and purposes, the U.S.A. is finished and will NEVER be restored.

This is what we deserve.

[ftf]

If we went through with a plan like that the nuclear fallout would probably half the expected lifespans of everyone on earth.

[angryChineseKahanist]

Either one can, but if I had to choose, I'd choose Israel.
The US would never do it.
However, whoever does it has to realize the consequences
of nukes. We want to kill muslim cockroaches without
burning any trees or ruining any lawn. Why dirty our
drinking water (or theirs)?
When you spray for bugs at home, you don't want your children
to touch the sticky residue.

Instead of nukes, we could just bomb them strait to hell and
bury their filthy corpses in the desert. Well have to use
Hazmat trucks to transport them though because their bodies
are highly toxic.

[Shlomo]

Neutron bombs are fairly clean and have an incredibly fast decay rate.

[cjd]

I think Israel should.  The reason for this is that it must be....literally....a light among the nations.  Give this world something really to complain about.  Blame them and later thank them...  I'd like to see Israel take out Damascus, Tehran, Mecca while America takes out Moscow, Beijing, Havana while India nukes Pakistan...  Lets get it on!!

Brilliant!

Wouldn't that be something!

What about China, though?

We're kidding ourselves if we think we can take China.

The WWII generation is no more.  We've become fat, lazy, stupid, selfish children.

For all intents and purposes, the U.S.A. is finished and will NEVER be restored.

This is what we deserve.

Any action against a country like China would have to be push button warfare. With the amount of people that China has attacking it would be like busting up a fire ant mound. They would climb over their dead in order to overrun any enemy and eat them alive. Bill Clinton has even put the crimp in our advantage in being able to take them out with nukes because he gave them missile technology that moved them ahead decades in the ability to launch a nuke at a enemy target. Even if China has  limited potential now soon they will be able to apply the old mutually assured destruction deterrent on us.  America should really stop dismantling her nuclear arsenal because the old enemies are still out there along with many new ones.

[angryChineseKahanist]

Any action against a country like China would have to
be push button warfare. With the amount of people that
China has attacking it would be like busting up
a fire ant mound. They would climb over their

Considering China's history of internal conflict and
corruption, I'd say, the US should not have to fire
a single shot. Perhaps a bunch of spys and some bribes.

Look, is China really communist anymore? Or just a greedy
capitalist? Either way, it's a dictatorship.

But we do need a nationalistic leader first.

[cjd]

Any action against a country like China would have to
be push button warfare. With the amount of people that
China has attacking it would be like busting up
a fire ant mound. They would climb over their

Considering China's history of internal conflict and
corruption, I'd say, the US should not have to fire
a single shot. Perhaps a bunch of spys and some bribes.

Look, is China really communist anymore? Or just a greedy
capitalist? Either way, it's a dictatorship.

But we do need a nationalistic leader first.

I may be nuts in my thinking but I liked China the way it was before it discovered capitalism. It keep to its self and the people were not into a consumer based culture. Today China compeats with America for the worlds resources causing prices to rise on things that were once quite a bit cheaper. When shortages start to take place I can see the resentment level raising and causing some real heated conflicts.

[MarZutra]

I think Israel should.  The reason for this is that it must be....literally....a light among the nations.  Give this world something really to complain about.  Blame them and later thank them...  I'd like to see Israel take out Damascus, Tehran, Mecca while America takes out Moscow, Beijing, Havana while India nukes Pakistan...  Lets get it on!!

Brilliant!

Wouldn't that be something!

What about China, though?

Sorry Jeffguy you are absolutly correct and this is exactly why Beijing must be made into a glass parking lot.  Of course there are many other cities that conventional carpet or fire bombing like the Brits did to Dresden....  This world has paid too high a price thanks to the Elitists, Egalitarian/Communism/Socialism/Gnosticisma and Islam...  BOOM!!   

China would fall more easily than Russia in my opinion.  The Chinese collective mind wouldn't know what to do once the head of the snake is severed.  Now you raise a great question about China and "capitalism".  In all actuality is not Capitalism but Elitist Communism exploiting their collective masses in wayge slavery thanks to the West which preaches "human rights", "workers right" and all that rubbish while we send all our industry over to these savages.   In all honesty I believe the Asian culture is the most savage, even below that of the Muslims and the African blacks....albeit all or tragically inhumane and revolting...

China and Russia have been in cooperation for many years.  Back in the 1970s-1980's the Communists faked a split between the two nations to gain more dollars from the West who wanted to exploit one agaisnt the other, in hopes (so they propagate) of one warring against the other.  The fact is the two had always been together and raped the west of technology, funding and of course expansion in nearly every nation on the planet....   terrible...

[Dr. Dan]

what?! bomb China!? what are you going to do for Moo Shu Pork?!

[Scriabin]

Jeffguy you are absolutly correct and this is exactly why Beijing must be made into a glass parking lot. 

China would fall more easily than Russia in my opinion.  The Chinese collective mind wouldn't know what to do once the head of the snake is severed. 
In all honesty I believe the Asian culture is the most savage, even below that of the Muslims and the African blacks....albeit all or tragically inhumane and revolting...

You've got to be kidding.   

[Carlyle]

Sorry but I can't see what strategic benefits a nuclear strike to Mecca could have.

Our first responsibility is to deal with the rogue state Iran.

[Shlomo]

I like getting everyone stirred up on this and I am laughing right now... I don't think we should just start nuking the world. And I definitely don't think we could take on China like that or that it would be a good idea at all. China has an incredible military force.

I've posted the question to Chaim on this week's program... we'll see what he says.

I do think that mecca is a scummy pile of garbage that should be destroyed. All the muslims would think allah abandon them and this could help crush the islamic nazi spirit. But this is my opinion and not the official JTF position.

I DO AGREE, HOWEVER, THAT WE SHOULD TAKE OUT THOSE NUCLEAR SITES IN IRAN! I am serious about this one point and this is the JTF position.

I also think they should utterly destroy that stupid mosque in Jerusalem.

I gotta run... I'm cutting it so close again. See you all tomorrow night!

[MassuhDGoodName]

Re:  "taking out China"

China's long history can be seen in terms of its struggle to prevent the breakdown of its society which has always occurred whenever its citizenry were free to act without an iron fisted leader keeping them in line.

It appears that modern China has begun to risk its own cohesion for the promise of quick technological and economic advancement.  Already, the corruption is running rampant, and the peoples' respect for and tolerance for their own dictatorship is diminishing.

What remains to be seen, is whether or not China will return to its usual state of chaotic anarchy ruled by feudal warlords, before its rising military is forced to pursue foreign military adventures which will be inevitably forced on them if they intend to control an overpopulation which will soon demand endless growth and increased income.

Since the Revolution, The Peoples' Republic of China has used the Republic of China as their primary propaganda tool to unite its people.  If the PRC one day were to actually seize Taiwan, a new "boogeyman" would have to immediately be found by China's leadership to replace their long-time nemesis.  China at that time would, in my opinion, pose a serious threat to the rest of the world.