A one-way ticket to Saudi-Arabia, the American converts would be sent first, so that they'd realize first hand what real Islam is all about.
Yes, that is good.
I would say: All islamo's: You have now overstayed your 'visit'. We are now giving Americans
their Sanctuary, this means you are no longer welcome.. You have tried to twist laws so that we would sympathize with your murderous ways and you did this, after people of YOUR 'religion' attacked US. You refuse to accept America and its freedoms, you dislpay this by the way you treat your wives, your evident hatred towards we the people, and we extended your stay too long. All people of the islamo 'religion' will now also be placed under citizens arrest should they try to escape- all islamos must report to the closest port, where we will ship you back to your homelands, that you love so well, should you refuse to comply, we will have no choice but to protect USA with individual self-defense against you, you will be allowed to take your qu'rans, and belonings, or they will be burned anyway.
Good Riddance.