2 us soldiers throw a puppy off the cliff youtube video

[Rubystars]

Do you have the link to the debunking video? I know a lot of bad stuff really does happen in the world, but it would help me to know that this particular incident wasn't real.

[Boeregeneraal]

yes, let me just get it for you.

lol, when i knew it was vastly edited, i found it quite funny 

[Boeregeneraal]

http://youtube.com/watch?v=N0xjY-4CMdI&feature=related

 

[Ultra Requete]

Exactly it can be trick of American piss now moverment, even if this is true it shud not be published,becouse it's used as anti US andanti military propagand. 

[Boeregeneraal]

If were smart about it, we can actually make a response video, showing what muslims do to animals!

This could be a good idea! What do you all think?

[SavetheWest]

Exactly it can be trick of American piss now moverment, even if this is true it shud not be published,becouse it's used as anti US andanti military propagand. 

http://youtube.com/watch?v=N0xjY-4CMdI&feature=related

 

I'd like to see the Marine investigation.  If they find nothing then it's definitely fake.  I just don't want to sound like those 9-11 conspiracy idiots with controlled demolition theories and Muslims who say Bin Laden is a marionette.

[Boeregeneraal]

well, atleast it's one less muslim 

[Serbian Cetnik (šumadinac)]

I value life exactly the same, but not the thing that we eat. I mean if someone started playfully killing a chicken id kill him too, if he just killed the chicken as a resource for food, thats a different thing.

I still would have killed him with a thin needle. the man is a foul image of god.

[Matt M.]

That's a strange way to judge the opinions here.  I don't know how you take attacking an evil person who kills baby animals for fun as a measurement by Jews to equate human and animal life. People here are against needless cruelty and there is no possible reason to kill a puppy, nor can there reasonably be one.  It shows that people on the forum, Jews and gentiles alike, don't think wearing a uniform makes you a good person.  It shows that people here are good and don't like to see an innocent animal be killed for no reason.  Many people have been saved by dogs and they often reflect the owners they have. It's also very unlikely that the soldier hasn't done other evil things and the Marines completely denounced this action.

I'm not defending the killing of puppies for no reason, but advocating human murder and torture over something like that is disgusting. Surely you condemn Muslims for becoming violent over Muhammed cartoons, yet you say a man should be killed because he harmed a dog. Both of these are examples of the same irrational thought process: Disproportionate Response. People who champion violence over the smallest things are the problem with the world, not the solution.

[Lewinsky Stinks, Dr. Brennan Rocks]

I'm not defending the killing of puppies for no reason, but advocating human murder and torture over something like that is disgusting. Surely you condemn Muslims for becoming violent over Muhammed cartoons, yet you say a man should be killed because he harmed a dog. Both of these are examples of the same irrational thought process: Disproportionate Response. People who champion violence over the smallest things are the problem with the world, not the solution.

Matt, you don't get it. Anybody who has such hatred and cruelty to an innocent being is seriously sociopathic and is potentially a threat to all civilization. Also, please remember that Iraqis and all other Muslims hate dogs (because Mohammed did), and that they likely did this little stunt to show "solidarity" with their sand-ape "friends".

[SavetheWest]

That's a strange way to judge the opinions here.  I don't know how you take attacking an evil person who kills baby animals for fun as a measurement by Jews to equate human and animal life. People here are against needless cruelty and there is no possible reason to kill a puppy, nor can there reasonably be one.  It shows that people on the forum, Jews and gentiles alike, don't think wearing a uniform makes you a good person.  It shows that people here are good and don't like to see an innocent animal be killed for no reason.  Many people have been saved by dogs and they often reflect the owners they have. It's also very unlikely that the soldier hasn't done other evil things and the Marines completely denounced this action.

I'm not defending the killing of puppies for no reason, but advocating human murder and torture over something like that is disgusting. Surely you condemn Muslims for becoming violent over Muhammed cartoons, yet you say a man should be killed because he harmed a dog. Both of these are examples of the same irrational thought process: Disproportionate Response. People who champion violence over the smallest things are the problem with the world, not the solution.

There is a big difference between becoming violent over a cartoon and someone throwing a puppy off a cliff. To make that comparison is to say satire and being violent towards an animal is the same, and it's not. I wouldn't and didn't suggest killing the soldier but he should receive a stiff sentence from the Marines for a number of reasons.  He makes the Marine Corps look terrible and hurts America's reputation among ally countries like India that take things like this more seriously.  There was no reason to do this and I don't blame people for being angry at this guy.  This soldier needs to get help but he probably won't, so I really don't care if he lives or dies.  He should just be punished for that action.  If he's willing to do this for fun, what else is he willing to do?

[Song of Silence]

I'll be damned if the people who sympathize with the puppy also happen to be meat-eaters.

[Serbian Cetnik (šumadinac)]

Im not chinese:P i dont eat pets:D

[Song of Silence]

Im not chinese:P i dont eat pets:D

LOL But you do eat meat, don't you? So isn't it a bit hypocritical to show compassion for a puppy (which is a good thing, BTW), and yet have no qualms about eating the flesh of slaughtered animals? How can a person do both?

[FULL METAL JACKET]

Im not chinese:P i dont eat pets:D

LOL But you do eat meat, don't you? So isn't it a bit hypocritical to show compassion for a puppy (which is a good thing, BTW), and yet have no qualms about eating the flesh of slaughtered animals? How can a person do both?

You don't see the difference between eating an animal for food, and throwing a pet puppy off a cliff? wow 

[Ulli]

These guys are asshats, it really amazes me how stupid all these fools are that they always film it,are they proud? imaginine doing a horrible thing like that and filming it.They should immediatly sent by their C.O. for psych evaluation.

Good point Mord. 

All fools filming their crimes and put it online 

Perhaps they know in their subconscious, that they are fools and that they deserve a hard punishment. 

[abdithefaithful]

These guys are asshats, it really amazes me how stupid all these fools are that they always film it,are they proud? imaginine doing a horrible thing like that and filming it.They should immediatly sent by their C.O. for psych evaluation.

Good point Mord. 

All fools filming their crimes and put it online 

Perhaps they know in their subconscious, that they are fools and that they deserve a hard punishment. 

They should receive a court marshal punishment from the Military that requires them to have to change wet  "wee wee pads" at "Puppy City" (a famed pet store in the NY area) for the rest of their lives... Let the punishment suit the crime...

[takebackourtemple]

At least there is some good news:

http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/06/12/marine.puppy/index.html

[JTFFan]

Im not chinese:P i dont eat pets:D

LOL But you do eat meat, don't you? So isn't it a bit hypocritical to show compassion for a puppy (which is a good thing, BTW), and yet have no qualms about eating the flesh of slaughtered animals? How can a person do both?

lol

[Serbian Cetnik (šumadinac)]

Im not chinese:P i dont eat pets:D

LOL But you do eat meat, don't you? So isn't it a bit hypocritical to show compassion for a puppy (which is a good thing, BTW), and yet have no qualms about eating the flesh of slaughtered animals? How can a person do both?

Serbs are complex ppl:P I can eat a lamb, while a dead enemy is next to me and my puppy is playing with his eyeball:P