Whatever I predicted everything here from the beginning, don't act like you're the first people it happens to on the right. Especially since you don't love the mudrats that fagbook staff is infested with.
Can you please make more than one page, for your own good? If you are trying for a death-pact on FB with who I think you are, good luck, but I wouldn't for an instant trust someone who thinks he's big. You need it with a lot of small pages with nothing to loose.
Also, for next time, the list of likes can be exported in excel format, and you can invite everyone back. That takes a while, so either make JTF 1,2,3,4 and 5, or make JTF on Islam, JTF on Israel, JTF on America, JTF on Education, JTF on Judaism, and a bunch of pages by topic.
Yes, you will "divide" things. You will also have the opportunity to connect with more types of people who are single issue, and not loose everything when they take you down again, and don't pretend like it isn't going to happen another ten times, especially if you're accomplishing something. Anyways conversations on facebook are of little use, you want them to go to the forum, or some less-fascist social media website.