General Category > Ask JTF

Ask JTF For Motza'ei Tzom Asara BeTevet, Sunday, December 31.

<< < (4/6) > >>

True Kahanist:
Dear chaim,

Firstly, I just want to thank you for answering my questions last week.

Secondly, I want to thank bagels for giving me the connection on how to contact Rabbi Kahane's Yeshiva.

Now before I ask my question I want to tell Yacov to go to kahanebooks.com. It took them a week to deliver my Kahane book, but they also have a connection to shops where you can buy Kahane books in New York and Jerusalem (this would be obviously cheaper as it doesn't include shipping costs). I called the shop in Jerusalem and they have many Kahane books. Just thought I should tell you this as you asked last week where the best place to buy Kahane books is. The payment method if you wish to buy through this website is paypal. Good luck (as it took me time to find out the best place to buy Kahane books).

Thanks Chaim for letting me know about McCarhty: the guy you were referring to last week was Roy Cohn

Now finally to my question: I know you support Ann coulter, but you need to find out in more detail about her support for Israel, because I am weary of her (a bit) until proven otherwise.

Toda Achi

OZ77:
Chaim shalom, I ran into this link:
http://jdo.org/
as a part of a post for a demonstration against neturei karta

they seem to have a training camp, they're called jewish defense organization (sounds familiar?)
what IS this group? is it the reincarnation of JDL or what?

10x,

OZ.

petre:
Yacov Menashe moved this vicious post here so Chaim can respond to it.

I am a religious Jew, and I came upon this site via a google search. Your ideology is extremely racist and reminiscent of the Nazis you rightly vilify. And, btw, I consider myself weary of Islam, conservative and in support of national defense. Your vilifying everyone in mainstream leadership and culture is abhorrent. Only you are good and every other Jew or non-Jew is bad? Where in your Torah does it say blacks or Spanish are inferior? In mine it's not mentioned. Not that I ever supported affirmative action or illegal immigration, but that does not cause me to hate every single black or Spanish for it.
I will refer you to this amazing site. The people on it agree with you on almost every issue ... that is everything except Israel. And one other, only minor, side point: they may agree with you, but they want you dead:

http://www.StørmFrønt.org

I am sure most Jews don't support your view and neither do most white Christians and those who do are anti-Semitic white segragtionists.

Johnson Brown:

--- Quote from: petre on December 25, 2006, 09:53:20 PM ---I am a religious Jew, and I came upon this site via a google search. Your ideology is extremely racist and reminiscent of the Nazis you rightly vilify. And, btw, I consider myself weary of Islam, conservative and in support of national defense. Your vilifying everyone in mainstream leadership and culture is abhorrent. Only you are good and every other Jew or non-Jew is bad? Where in your Torah does it say blacks or Spanish are inferior? In mine it's not mentioned. Not that I ever supported affirmative action or illegal immigration, but that does not cause me to hate every single black or Spanish for it.
I will refer you to this amazing site. The people on it agree with you on almost every issue ... that is everything except Israel. And one other, only minor, side point: they may agree with you, but they want you dead:

http://www.StørmFrønt.org

--- End quote ---
The Torah doesn't say all blacks and Spanish are inferior or criminals but just look around, are you from the real world.
No one on this forum ever said ALL blacks and Spanish are inferior they are saying Most which no one can argue, they breed crime and violence in tremendous amounts not to mention unwanted babies that they want everyone to support through welfare programs.

adam613:
  Hi Chaim. I have listening to some of the Kahanist Audio's from Kahane.org and from your tube on Masada2000. Obviously, Rabbi Kahane ZT"L is no longer around today but going forward I did want to point out something which in my honest opinion was the wrong approach.

I always hear Rabbi Kahane, mention that what will happen when the "Arabs become the majority". I have three problems with using this as the rallying point. Firstly, this to me was conceding the fact that Arab woman will have more babies then Jewish woman would and trusting Arab's in having children more then trusting Jews. To be honest if Rabbi Kahane was going to implement a free market economy and privatize business, and have no affirmative action for Arabs, and not have a welfare state for Arabs or anyone except maybe the real needy among some of his reforms wouldn't Jews have a higher birth rate then Arabs. So I feel his constant worry about "what happens when Arabs become the majority" showed that he did not believe that Arab birthrates could or would go down and/or that there were  ways to increase the birth rates of married Jewish women and higher rates of married young Jewish women in the first place so that the Jewish birth rate would be higher then the Arabs birth rate. I do know the Arab birth rates were overstated somewhat although they are greater (4.0 vs 2.6 from one source) then the Jewish rate nevertheless.

My second problem with this "what happens when the Arabs become the majority" is a fifth column is fifth column no matter what their numbers are. Yes, the larger they are the more dangerous they are  but a country has the right to expel a legitimate fifth column and from what I understand it has been done historically. It was done with a country removing German because they viewed them as a fifth column.(don't remember the country).  As a minority the Arabs were helping in the killing of Jews (one Jew killed is too many) and voting for politicians that openly called for the destruction of Israel. By focusing on a hypothetical in the future I think he gave the false impression that as a minority the Israeli Arabs were good citizens which isn't true. And if they are OK as a minority then I do think to say we have to expell them because they will become a majority sets a bad precedence for any other country with a religious minority. The fact was they were a fifth column as a minority and there was plenty of evidence of this and THAT is what should have been focused on by Rabbi Kahane not some hypothetical which gives the false impression that TODAY the Israeli Arabs are good citizens as minorities which is a completely false assertion.
  
 The third problem is there was also the legitimate expulsion of Jews from Arab lands without compensation. Rabbi Kahane could have focused on that and the legitimate transfer issue as that also his historical precedence with other countries that transferred population. (India and Pakistan with Muslims and Hindus.)

     Yes he likely would have been called a racist anyway but there is historical precedence for the second and third problems I raised. I don't know of any good case of a country expelling a minority because it will become a majority. Also, as flawed as the Israeli democracy is to tell everyone that your system is worthless when there were other ways to do this through the flawed democracy  (with problem two or three above) this open contempt for the flawed democracy may have caused a larger number of people in the government and courts to dislike him then otherwise. I just think it was being over the top when it was unnecessary and there were other ways to do this. Just my honest opinion from what I know.
  
    Thanks and happy birthday and you should have many more. I hope one day Jews can be confident in having a higher average birthrate then their enemies.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page