I already said that herzl suggested that Jews will convert to Christianety:
A. Nothing is antisimetic in that suggestion.
nothing is anti-semitic / self hating, about a jew whose goal is that all jews become christian.
Nothing is anti-semitic about a jew who says that a simple christian is greater than a jewish rabbi?
Nothing is anti-semitic about a man who thinks that only as christians can jews be free and proud.
He hated judaism. He hated the religious jew.
B. Herzl changed his mind later.
Herzl also wanted that the Jewish will be in Uganda, that we would speak German etc', this movie is nonsense and is telling a lot of lies.
<sarcasm>
Oh, if he wanted a jewish state in Uganda, that proves he is no anti-semite.
</sarcasm>
Lets start shortly:
*The quote of Mendelson "Be Jewish in your house and a Man outside it" don't mean that Jews aren't human, that's nonsense and just bull$hit. It means that you should'nt have a definion as "Jewish" so you could be "fine" with the gentile, be just "a man".
funny to see you defend that one. That is not what it means.
I live in Britain, a variation of that was passed down, one of my great grandfathers. It was to be a Jew in the home, and a gentleman outside.
There is a bit of a bad implication there. But I sympathise with that statement. Even nowadays I hear Orthodox jews say they do not want to wear a tallit outdoors (e.g. on shabbat when no eruv), because it flaunts their jewishness in the non-jews faces. I would hope that jews nowadays know that anti-semites will hate us regardless. But I understand this concern, as a mechanism against anti-semitism.
This is not a major point in the video.
Notice that the next person or the one after that, they interview , covesr Jabotinsky. about 26min in.
And he says that Jews who refuse to cut their beards should not be allowed to vote.
Don`t defend that, please. I know you don`t have a beard, but have some self respect. Sorry if I am too tough, I know you are only 11 ;-)
*The quote of Josef Haim Brenner is so called antisimetic qoute, nonsense, he is talking about the disporal Jew, the wimp that fear from the gentiles so much. JDL was org. that created to defend that disporal Jews that Josef Haim Brenner talked about.
I am not going to watch the movie again beacuse it's very long. But just note how 99% is out of contenst.
The JDL empowered diaspora jews to fight anti-semites.
This anti-semitic slime is saying that diaspora jews are subhuman. And that they deserve anti-semitism.
You cannot in your right mind, compare that to the JDL. Which taught Jewish Pride. (regardless of where the jew lived).
Topic: Secular Zionism - Israel`s founders - shocking video, from shofar.net / amnon yi (Read 15090 times)